All spirits Bourbon Scotch Whiskey Tequila Mezcal Rum Gin Vodka Brandy Liqueur Ready to Drink Everything else Taste finder Brands

Filters

1 filter on Clear all

Easy to buy

Only bottles with a live Total Wine price, not out of stock or members-only.

Under $30 $300 and up

Tiers, not live prices: Under $30 through $300 and up.

4.5+ Exceptional 4.2+ Very good 4.0+ Good 3.5+ Decent Any rating

ABV %

Age (years)

Age filters skip bottles with no age statement.

Anyone 25 people 100 people 500 people

A thin score moves a lot with one more review.

Rhum Agricole Vieux 14 Navy Rum 10 Rhum Agricole Blanc 6 Rhum Agricole Eleve Sous Bois 1

Clear

Catalog

Every bottle

165 bottles 3.94 median score $37 median price 9,479 ratings

Filter (1) Easy to find / buy Showing 25–48 of 165 bottles 165 bottles

Hogo

#25

Privateer

Privateer The Queen's Share Rum

Rum Aged Rum Massachusettes 60.5% ABV

Aged Rum · Massachusettes

Above average of rum

4.18 4.2 out of 5 2626 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#26

Yongehurst Distillery Harbour Rum

Rum Silver Rum Ontario 44% ABV

Silver Rum · Ontario

5.00 5.0 out of 5 33 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#27

Hamilton

Hamilton Overproof 151 Rum

Rum Gold Rum Guyana 75.5% ABV

Gold Rum · Guyana

Above average of rum

4.14 4.1 out of 5 4141 ratings

$35.99 Total Wine

#28

Mount Gilboa Rum

Rum Aged Rum Barbados 40% ABV

Aged Rum · Barbados

4.25 4.3 out of 5 44 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#29

Two James

Two James Doctor Bird Jamaican Rum

Rum Aged Rum Jamaica 50% ABV

Aged Rum · Jamaica

Above average of rum

4.08 4.1 out of 5 6464 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#30

Denizen

Denizen Merchant's Reserve 8 Year Rum

Rum Aged Rum Multiple Countries 43% ABV

Aged Rum · Multiple Countries

Above average of rum

4.12 4.1 out of 5 3838 ratings

$30.99 Total Wine

#31

Planteray

Planteray Extrême No. 3 Jamaica ITP 1996

Rum Aged Rum Jamaica 54.8% ABV

Aged Rum · Jamaica

4.05 4.1 out of 5 66 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#32

Cap Savanna Rhum Vieux 7

Rum Aged Rum Réunion Island 43% ABV

Aged Rum · Réunion Island

4.05 4.1 out of 5 66 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#33

Planteray

Planteray O.F.T.D. Overproof Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 69% ABV

Dark Rum · Multiple Countries

Above average of rum

4.06 4.1 out of 5 200200 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#34

Bristol

Bristol Port Morant Demerara Rum 1999

Rum Aged Rum Guyana 46% ABV

Aged Rum · Guyana

4.00 4.0 out of 5 22 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#35

St. Lucia

St. Lucia Distillers 1931 (3rd Edition)

Rum Aged Rum Saint Lucia 43% ABV

Aged Rum · Saint Lucia

Above average of rum

4.06 4.1 out of 5 1212 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#36

Planteray

Planteray Extrême No. 3 Jamaica HJC 1996

Rum Aged Rum Jamaica 56.2% ABV

Aged Rum · Jamaica

5.00 5.0 out of 5 22 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#37

Black Tot Last

Black Tot Last Consignment British Royal Navy Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 54.8% ABV

Dark Rum · Multiple Countries

Above average of rum

4.31 4.3 out of 5 1313 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#38

Neisson

Neisson Rhum Agricole Reserve Speciale

Rum Rhum Agricole Martinique 42% ABV

Rhum Agricole · Martinique

Above average of rum

4.19 4.2 out of 5 1515 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#39

Novo Fogo

Novo Fogo Tanager Cachaça

Rum Cachaca Paraná 40% ABV

Cachaca · Paraná

Above average of rum

3.96 4.0 out of 5 1919 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#40

Ten to One Five Origin Select

Rum Aged Rum Multiple Countries 46% ABV

Aged Rum · Multiple Countries

3.85 3.9 out of 5 55 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#41

Smith

Smith & Cross Traditional Jamaica Rum

Rum Dark Rum Jamaica 57% ABV

Dark Rum · Jamaica

Above average of rum

4.03 4.0 out of 5 261261 ratings

$43.99 Total Wine

#42

Tiki Lovers

Tiki Lovers White Rum

Rum Silver Rum Multiple Countries 50% ABV

Silver Rum · Multiple Countries

4.19 4.2 out of 5 44 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#43

Novo Fogo

Novo Fogo Single Barrel 86 Cachaça

Rum Cachaca Paraná 48% ABV

Cachaca · Paraná

92 critic score

$30–$50 Estimated range

#44

Rum Fire White Overproof

Rum Silver Rum Jamaica 63% ABV

Silver Rum · Jamaica

Above average of rum

4.11 4.1 out of 5 3636 ratings

Under $30 Estimated range

#45

Rum Society

The Rum Society No. 40

Rum Silver Rum Guyana 40% ABV

Silver Rum · Guyana

4.50 4.5 out of 5 22 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#46

Land Legs Rum

Rum Silver Rum Oregon 40% ABV

Silver Rum · Oregon

5.00 5.0 out of 5 11 rating

Under $30 Estimated range

#47

Below Deck

Below Deck Silver Rum

Rum Silver Rum Oregon 40% ABV

Silver Rum · Oregon

4.80 4.8 out of 5 55 ratings

Under $30 Estimated range

#48

Ten To One Caribbean

Ten To One Caribbean Dark Rum

Rum Dark Rum Multiple Countries 40% ABV

Dark Rum · Multiple Countries

Above average of rum

4.27 4.3 out of 5 2020 ratings

$37.99 Total Wine