Skip to content
Sip Curator
Watershed Four Peel Gin
Watershed

Watershed Four Peel Gin

4.06 Good

22 reviews22 ratings

Above average for gin

Gin Modern Gin Ohio No age statement 44% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This gin is characterized by a botanical profile featuring four types of citrus peel: grapefruit, orange, lemon, and lime. It is bottled at 88 proof.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 5 parsed reviews.

Marcel Holbrook 3.5

Bottle #016645 Given my strong preference for citrus notes in gin, this bottling sparked considerable anticipation. The other listed botanicals are quite basic, leading me to hope the citrus would truly stand out. Furthermore, it's always interesting to discover if distilleries in Ohio can produce quality spirits. Evidently, the presence of all four distilled citrus fruits is unmistakable on the nose. Juniper and coriander are also detectable, though they follow the citrus. There's an even fainter hint of black pepper, alongside a scent resembling industrial cleaner. So far, it's rather straightforward, and I hope the ingredients deliver on their promise. The initial taste is somewhat peppery, creating an expectation of greater spice than is ultimately delivered. The citrus soon dominates, clearly imparting the zest and pith of all four advertised citrus varieties. This evolves into citrus oil and, as the finish approaches, becomes notably sweet while maintaining its citrus focus. At 88 proof, I didn't anticipate a strong burn, yet it's less intense than expected, concluding primarily with the fruit flavors. This is an outstanding spirit with prominent fruit and citrus characteristics. However, it lacks the key elements that define a quality gin, failing to express spice, juniper, or floral notes effectively. It holds significant potential in cocktails, likely excelling in martinis, but drinking it neat makes it difficult to classify as a gin. If you're searching for a gin with pronounced citrus flavor, this is it, though it perhaps overdoes it slightly. Ohio remains on the map for now.

Daryl Mcclain 3.5

As the name suggests, this gin is heavy on citrus. This bottle, along with Bluecoat, taught me I'm not into citrus-forward gins. If you prefer citrus over herbs or juniper, this is a good choice for you. It's also great to support local breweries from my region.

Micah Ferraro 4.5

The initial gin I enjoyed. It has a pleasant citrus essence from lemon, lime, grapefruit, and orange peels. Ideal in a gin Collins or gin Rickey. Created locally in Columbus, Ohio.

Adeline Sutherland 4.0

Completing a review from tastings years ago. If you want a gin, these people are the place to go. And this is their basic gin. Try it and if you like gin, you'll buy another.

Warren Whipple 4.0

The citrus aroma is beautiful, it's mellow and full-bodied and enjoyable even to someone who normally dislikes gin

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Modern Gin
Cutler's Gin
Cutler's

Cutler's Gin

Modern Gin California
4.8 /5 5 $30–$50
Koval Dry Gin
Koval

Koval Dry Gin

Modern Gin Illinois
4.1 /5 60 $30–$50