Skip to content
Sip Curator
Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum
Captain Morgan

Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum

2.93 Mixed reviews

754 reviews754 ratings

78 critic score

Rum Spiced Rum US Virgin Islands No age statement 35% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Henry Morgan, born in Wales in 1635, served the British government as a privateer, prisoner, admiral, and knight. He passed away as the Lieutenant Governor of Jamaica at the age of 53. The rum bearing his name was introduced in 1983. Since 2010, its distillery has been located in the U.S. Virgin Islands, having moved from Puerto Rico. In April 2023, Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum was reformulated with real Madagascar Vanilla and updated packaging.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Sweet 85
Rich 80
Spicy 50
Fruity 45
Oily 40
Roast 20
Woody 20
Smoky 15

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 50 parsed reviews.

Janel Cheney 1.0

Nose - sweet corn candy, marshmallow, confectioners' sugar, dark syrup, a breakfast cereal, sugared orange peel, dulce de leche, soda pop, vanilla, peppercorns, slight alcohol sting. Palate - sweet corn candy, confectioners' sugar, dulce de leche, soda pop, vanilla, peppercorns, slight alcohol sting, ending quickly with notes of vanilla, sweet corn candy, and soda pop. I concur with the professional assessment. A definite state fair candy vibe is present. The aroma is incredibly sugary, featuring prominent vanilla, confectioners' sugar, and soda pop notes. It verges on overly sweet, but narrowly avoids being entirely dreadful. Conversely, the taste is truly awful. It's quite dull and nauseatingly sweet, strongly resembling a faux-sweetened and spiced Canadian Spirit. The conclusion is similarly vile, with any hint of flavor vanishing instantly, leaving only that dull, saccharine sweetness until you discover something to cleanse your palate. Not advised for anything other than mixing with cola, though superior choices exist even for that purpose.

Sandra Liang 2.0

After getting my initial scent impressions, I detected vanilla and wood aromas. If the flavor matched the fragrance, I'd give it a strong endorsement. Yet, I sampled it neat for an honest evaluation, and instantly, my palate was overwhelmed by ethanol. The taste was intensely ethanol-forward; the vanilla and wood scents I perceived were completely absent. When mixed with Coca-Cola, the ethanol character vanished, transforming the spirit into a very sweet, sugary profile with faint, almost imperceptible, woody undertones. This is undeniably an economical choice, not suited for solo enjoyment unless ethanol is your preferred flavor. If that's the case, this platform or any reviews here won't be helpful; perhaps explore offerings at a convenience store for selections more aligned with your preferences.

Christian Zuniga 1.3

This is a pleasant drink for a teenager who enjoys stronger alcohol but lacks discernment in rums. As one matures, preferences change. With few exceptions, this rum ranks below basic Havana and even below basic Bacardí, yet it's priced similarly, giving me no reason to choose it. It's nice and affordable for newcomers, but if you're looking for the fundamentals of Morgan's, you won't be disappointed. My days of heavy drinking are over, and nobody enjoys heartburn.

Judah Danner 2.5

This is a rich, spiced rum from the US Virgin Islands, produced using a combination of yeasts, molasses, water, and mash, then distilled continuously. The rum ages for up to a year before spices and flavors native to the Caribbean Islands are added. It presents an aromatic beginning with notes of molasses and spices; its rich life introduces caramel and vanilla; culminating in a rich, medium-length finish. December 2021

Marcus Warden 2.8

The aroma is intense with hints of ethanol, spice, and sugar candy, finishing with some vanilla. The palate is a bit rough but not unpleasant, revealing more sweetness and sugars alongside vanilla and a whisper of butterscotch, concluding with a pronounced alcohol warmth. It began promisingly but is best suited for cocktails rather than sipping neat.

Efrain Beasley 2.5

This spirit's color is a light amber. It smells strongly of vanilla. The taste is mostly vanilla extract, with hints of cinnamon and clove. It's sweet and has a noticeable amount of fusel alcohol. This is best used as a mixer.

44 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Spiced Rum
Tuaca

Tuaca

Herbal Liqueur Canada
3.0 /5 18 Under $30