Skip to content
Sip Curator
Booker's Bourbon Batch 2016-03 "Toogie's Invitation"
Booker's

Booker's Bourbon Batch 2016-03 "Toogie's Invitation"

4.01 Good

66 reviews66 ratings

89 critic score Above average for whiskey

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 6 Year 64.5% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

The third release in Booker's Bourbon's 2016 series, named "Toogie's Invitation," came out in June. It honors Marilyn “Toogie” Dick, a long-time friend of the family who knew the late distiller Booker and his wife Annis Noe from high school and was part of the original group that selected early Booker's batches. Distiller Fred Noe chose 375 barrels of Kentucky bourbon, aged at least 6 years, 4 months, and 4 days, from six different rack-houses for this bottling. It is presented at cask strength, 64.5% ABV, consistent with the series.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Rich 90
Sweet 80
Fruity 60
Spicy 40
Vanilla 40
Herbal 30
Oily 25

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 14 parsed reviews.

Willie Mays 4.8

APPEARANCE: Resembles Rich Maple Syrup. Viscous and clingy in the glass, forming small, slow-moving legs. NOSE: Sweet with notes of Burnt Brown Sugar, Vanilla, Peanut Brittle, and Kellogg's Corn Pops Cereal. It smells incredibly sticky, with hints of Orange Peel and Oak appearing later, joined by Cinnamon. Surprisingly little heat on the nose despite the high proof. NEAT: Wow! Incredibly potent and delicious. Orange Peel is prominent, followed by Vanilla and Honey. The characteristic Beam Peanut flavor is present but sweeter. A slightly medicinal Cherry note is also detected. The Oak feels a bit astringent. The finish is long and satisfying, leaving a lingering taste of Burnt Peanut Brittle. The high proof begins to numb the tongue, so a small addition of spring water is beneficial. SPLASH: A little water intensifies the Orange flavor, adding Cinnamon and Black Pepper. More water removes the astringency, bringing forth Brown Sugar and Sticky Caramel. It transforms into a liquid version of an old-school McDonald's Caramel Sundae with Peanuts. VERDICT: While not a huge fan of Beam generally, I regret not trying Booker's sooner. This was an excellent purchase made just before a price increase. If you can find it, look for this bottle. It's among the best bourbons I've ever experienced. After being home for an extended period, I opened this from the back of the cabinet. I might review another soon, as Elmer T Lee and Forged Oak have a high bar to clear.

Celia Navarrete 4.8

(#2) A fellow whiskey enthusiast recently shared their favorite whiskeys of 2020, and I found the concept so compelling that I've decided to adopt it. The criteria for inclusion wasn't novelty, but rather that the whiskey was new to my experience in 2020. Consequently, my list will feature a blend of familiar favorites and recent releases. I quickly narrowed down my initial selection of 14 possibilities to 7, but refining it from 7 to the final 5 proved more challenging. I'll also be presenting honorable mentions after revealing my top choice. I'll refrain from providing a complete re-evaluation of each, offering instead a general impression. If you're keen to read the full review, a brief scroll through my tasting history should reveal them. So, without further delay, I present my second-ranked whiskey of 2020... Apologies for the slight delay. Returning to my Top 5, here is my second-ranked whiskey of 2020. As previously noted in my review of another bottling, I was surprised to have two (or three, if you consider another) from the same producer on my list. This particular bottle was acquired online from a retailer for approximately $40, just before a price increase was announced. Upon opening it in March, I immediately regretted not buying more. I characterized this one as "Intense. Thick, Adherent, Wonderful Intensity." It presented more citrus notes than I typically expect from this producer. With a small addition of water, it transformed into something akin to an old-fashioned fast-food dessert with crushed nuts. While I'm uncertain of its standing among the various offerings from this brand, it ranks among the finest whiskeys I've ever had the pleasure of tasting.

Lia Hawley 3.8

Star anise and the scent of melted butter on the nose right away. Beyond those and more typical bourbon aromas, it pleasantly smells like a rotting, moss-covered log, making six years feel like sixty. More anise and licorice on the palate, with toasted cashews and caramel corn. The finish stops time internally, but on your lips, this bourbon is so alcoholic it evaporates in three seconds.

Lewis Fallon 4.5

Nose- loads of vanilla and caramel Taste- more complex than I am accustomed to. Numerous vanilla, oak, and nut notes. Smoky. The 129 proof delivers a notable burn. Finish- the taste persists and the burn is easily drinkable. It has been aged more than 6 years and it shows. One of the finest bourbons I have ever encountered. Good smoke and spice with excellent flavor. Water diminishes the flavor but not the burn. Better than another drink.

Frankie Pollock

The least desirable of the entire collection. It doesn't even improve when mixed. Apologies, but I'm not skilled with tasting notes, however, when you are a fan of Booker's and have sampled all the others, this is nearly rancid.

Al Mcmullen 4.0

The aroma offers notes of caramel, cinnamon, and bread. A palate of baking spices, vanilla, and toffee, along with a robust warmth, leads to a toasted vanilla and slightly sweet finish. It's not the best batch, but it's good.

8 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Bourbon