Skip to content
Sip Curator
J. Henry & Sons 5 Year Small Batch Wisconsin Straight Bourbon
J. Henry

J. Henry & Sons 5 Year Small Batch Wisconsin Straight Bourbon

3.75 Decent

179 reviews179 ratings

87 critic score

Whiskey Bourbon Wisconsin 5 Year 46% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

J. Henry and Sons bourbon is derived from grain cultivated on the family's own fields in Dane, Wisconsin. The mash bill incorporates a special heirloom red corn variety, developed in collaboration with the University of Wisconsin in 1939. The whiskey was produced in partnership with 45th Parallel Spirits and aged on the Henry farm, experiencing the "wild Wisconsin weather."

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Sweet 60
Rich 50
Fruity 40
Spicy 30
Vanilla 30
Herbal 20
Tart 15

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 49 parsed reviews.

Sandra Woodruff 4.0

We're getting ready to relocate to the Wisconsin countryside this summer; it will be a major change from apartment living in the city to residing on a small farm outside a village. While it represents many positive shifts, it's still a significant transition. I decided to prepare my palate by sampling the most celebrated Wisconsin whiskey, produced relatively close to our new home. The aroma is immediate – a really fresh, crisp scent of caramel apples lightly dusted with spice. Vanilla follows. The palate is exceptionally smooth for a five-year-old bourbon; rich and buttery, with notes of dulce de leche, apple, corn cereal, vanilla, a touch of cinnamon, and a finish like dark chocolate. If life in Wisconsin is as good as this bourbon, we're in for a wonderful experience!

Robyn Royer 4.0

Aroma: Overwhelmingly sweet candy and toasted wood. Faint hints of peppermint and cherries. Taste: Sadly, it doesn't quite live up to the impressive smell. The sweet candy and distinctive wood notes are still there, but I anticipated more based on the aroma. It's thin, with a pleasant, moderately long vanilla aftertaste. The sweetness is reminiscent of a dessert. I was initially considering a score of 3.75, but the more I drank it, the more I appreciated the flavor. I'll give it a 4, though I'd say it's closer to 3.9. Overall: Imagine a slightly diluted version of OF 1910.

Cortney Durham 3.3

At 92 proof, this bourbon is smooth and sweet. Its flavor profile is unique and unlike anything I've had before. I couldn't quite pinpoint the unique flavor, but upon seeing fig in the producer's literature, I had to agree: it's fig and honey. There are strong notes of vanilla and cinnamon, finishing with oak and wheat. I find I prefer J. Henry's single barrel releases more.

Malia Yee 5.0

Swirl the whiskey in the glass to observe its deep orangish amber color. The aroma offers notes of chocolate, toffee, caramel, and a subtle hint of sweet fruit. Upon tasting, you'll experience custard, crème brûlée, brioche, orange, and toffee that coat the palate. The custard notes return for a long, lingering finish. This is an exceptional Bourbon that may be unknown to you! Cheers!

Misty Myrick 4.0

A small-batch bourbon from Wisconsin, bottled at 92 proof. The liquid displays a golden brown hue, similar to the color of my preferred flannel shirt. The aroma reveals deep notes of chocolate and oak. The initial taste is light and easy, with the second sip unveiling a young whiskey character featuring oak, allspice, and brown sugar notes. A decent sipper considering its age and proof.

Ivory Schafer 3.5

Refined corn aroma, mixed with, I'd say apples, prairie wind, and a little caramel. I don't know how to describe the rest except to say it's quite unique and pretty good. Definitely worth buying if you're passing through Wisconsin.

43 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Bourbon