All spirits Bourbon Scotch Whiskey Tequila Mezcal Rum Gin Vodka Brandy Liqueur Ready to Drink Everything else Taste finder Brands

Filters

Current selection

Starlight Brand

Easy to buy

Only bottles with a live Total Wine price, not out of stock or members-only.

Under $30 $300 and up

Tiers, not live prices: Under $30 through $300 and up.

4.5+ Exceptional 4.2+ Very good 4.0+ Good 3.5+ Decent Any rating

ABV %

Age (years)

Age filters skip bottles with no age statement.

Anyone 25 people 100 people 500 people

A thin score moves a lot with one more review.

Other Whiskey 3 Wheat Whiskey 2 American Blended Whiskey 1 American Brandy 1 Corn 1

USA 191

Indiana 159 Kentucky 1 North America 1

Clear

Brand

Starlight

191 bottlings 3.99 median score $50–$100 typical price 649 ratings

Starlight Single Barrel Huber's Old Rickhouse Indiana Rye

Whiskey Rye Indiana 58.1% ABV

Rye · Indiana

3.77 3.8 out of 5 2222 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#74

Starlight

Starlight Distillery Peach Whiskey

Whiskey Flavored Whiskey Indiana 42% ABV

Flavored Whiskey · Indiana

3.83 3.8 out of 5 22 ratings

Under $30 Estimated range

#75

Starlight

Starlight Carl T Huber's

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 54% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.88 3.9 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#76

Starlight

Starlight Old Rickhouse Indiana Straight Rye Whiskey Small Batch (Batch No. 0002)

Whiskey Rye Indiana 46% ABV

Rye · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 11 rating

$30–$50 Estimated range

#77

Starlight

Starlight Single Barrel Bourbon - Distillery Hand Fill

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 58% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#78

Starlight

Starlight Distillery Carl T. Huber's Single Barrel Rye Whiskey Finished in Cognac Barrels

Whiskey Rye Indiana 54.7% ABV

Rye · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#79

Starlight

starlight Distillery Bourbon Whiskey Finished in Sauternes Barrels (Waterford Wine & Spirts Store Pick)

Whiskey Bourbon USA 52% ABV

Bourbon · USA

3.75 3.8 out of 5 11 rating

Under $30 Estimated range

#80

Starlight

Starlight Indiana Straight Bourbon Whiskey 2022 Single Cask 7 (Lost Lantern)

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 58% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#81

Starlight

Starlight Grappa

Everything else Other Spirits Indiana 40% ABV

Other Spirits · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 11 rating

Under $30 Estimated range

#82

Starlight

Starlight Straight Bourbon Whiskey Port Barrel Finished (Special Limited Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 47.5% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 11 rating

$30–$50 Estimated range

#83

Starlight

Starlight Light Whiskey

Whiskey American Whiskey Indiana 69.6% ABV

American Whiskey · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 33 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#84

Starlight

Starlight Bourbon Whiskey Finished in Champagne Wine Barrels

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 52.3% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 33 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#85

Starlight

Starlight Carl Huber's Double Oaked Bourbon Finished in Rye Whiskey Barrels

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 56% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 33 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#86

Starlight

Starlight Applejack

Brandy Indiana 41.5% ABV

Brandy · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 33 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#87

Starlight

Starlight Huber's Master Distiller Rickhouse Select Single Barrel Wheat Whiskey

Whiskey American Whiskey Indiana 55.8% ABV

American Whiskey · Indiana

3.75 3.8 out of 5 22 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#88

Starlight

Starlight Distillery Carl T. Huber's Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey Finished in VDN Barrels

Whiskey Bourbon USA 52.6% ABV

Bourbon · USA

3.75 3.8 out of 5 22 ratings

Under $30 Estimated range

#89

Starlight

Starlight Single Barrel Huber's Old Rickhouse Rye Finished in Honey Barrels (Selected by Binny's)

Whiskey Rye Indiana 55.2% ABV

Rye · Indiana

3.67 3.7 out of 5 33 ratings

$50–$100 Estimated range

#90

Starlight

Starlight Carl T. Hiber's Rickhouse Select Single Barrel Indiana Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 57.5% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.50 3.5 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#91

Starlight

Starlight Distillery Rye Whiskey Finished in PX Sherry Barrels

Whiskey Rye Indiana 52.3% ABV

Rye · Indiana

3.50 3.5 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#92

Starlight

Starlight Bourbon Whiskey Finished In Armagnac Barrels

Whiskey Bourbon USA 100% ABV

Bourbon · USA

3.50 3.5 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#93

Starlight

Starlight Single Barrel Huber's Indigenous Rye

Whiskey Rye Indiana 57.4% ABV

Rye · Indiana

3.50 3.5 out of 5 11 rating

$50–$100 Estimated range

#94

Starlight

Starlight Toasted Barrel Bourbon

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 53% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.69 3.7 out of 5 88 ratings

$100–$300 Estimated range

#95

Starlight

Starlight Indiana Straight Rye Single Barrel (Big Red Liquors)

Whiskey Rye Indiana 57.9% ABV

Rye · Indiana

3.67 3.7 out of 5 66 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

#96

Starlight

Starlight Carl T. Huber's Bottled in Bond Bourbon

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 50% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

3.65 3.7 out of 5 66 ratings

$30–$50 Estimated range

Best of the range

Highest weighted scores from this brand.

Starlight

Starlight Carl T. Huber's Cigar Batch Bourbon Finished in Brazilian Amburana Barrels

Bourbon Indiana

4.2 /5 41 $50–$100

Starlight

Starlight Bourbon Whiskey finished in Honey Barrels

Bourbon USA

4.5 /5 7 Under $30

Starlight

Starlight Carl T. Huber's Single Barrel Bourbon Finished in Cognac Barrels

Bourbon Indiana

4.2 /5 10 $50–$100

Starlight

Starlight Old Rickhouse Huber's Double Oaked Rye

Rye Indiana

4.0 /5 17 $50–$100

Starlight

Starlight Carl T. Huber's Single Barrel Bourbon Finished in Maple Syrup Barrels

Bourbon Indiana

4.0 /5 21 $50–$100

Starlight

Starlight Carl T Huber's Cigar Batch Finished in Amburana Rum Barrels R/Bourbon pick

Bourbon Indiana

4.9 /5 2 $100–$300