Skip to content
Sip Curator
The Real McCoy 12 Year Rum
Real McCoy

The Real McCoy 12 Year Rum

3.80 Decent

63 reviews63 ratings

87 critic score Above average for rum

Rum Aged Rum Barbados 12 Year 40% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

William McCoy was among the original rum runners, illicitly transporting rum into the United States during Prohibition. His refusal to adulterate his spirits for increased profit, unlike other bootleggers, led to "the real McCoy" becoming synonymous with authenticity. In 2012, documentary filmmaker Bailey Pryor, after producing a film about McCoy, launched The Real McCoy Spirits. All Real McCoy rums are sourced from the respected Foursquare Distillery in Barbados, which also supplied William historically. This expression is a blend of pot and column-still rums, aged for twelve years without any added sugar or coloring.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Woody 50
Fruity 50
Hogo 40
Roast 30
Floral 30
Spicy 25
Rich 20
Tart 20

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 19 parsed reviews.

Blaine Fish 4.0

This is a rum for bourbon fans. A quirky way to put it, meaning if bourbon is your thing, you'll probably enjoy this. It clearly tastes like rum, yet the texture, the woody sweetness, and even the hue bring to mind a good, unadulterated bourbon. The twelve years in bourbon casks undoubtedly contributed. Actually, forget 'contributed.' It has truly shaped it. Or perhaps 'made it this way.' Or if those linguistic choices are too crude for your palate, invent your own phrasing – honestly, just leave me be. I've been swamped lately by these hecklers who shadow my every word, finding fault with my writing.

Reed Fischer 1.3

To me, it has minimal scent of funk and bourbon, alongside nail polish if I must mention it. The flavor is bourbon and dry oak leaves on the finish. Strange, I know, but that's what came to mind. When sipped quickly, it has a smoothness on the tongue, and the pepper intensifies after swallowing. This was a letdown, as I had higher expectations for an aged spirit. It doesn't even taste good in soda. The rating is based on neat sipping.

Lacy Shell 3.8

Fruit and vanilla on the nose, oak and petroleum on the tongue. A good swirl in the mouth brings back the vanilla and fruit with a hint of caramel. As it goes down, the petrol reappears, accompanied by a warmth. Nothing extreme, and all fairly pleasant, though perhaps not as smooth or satisfying as the three-year-old version.

Nanette Terrazas 4.3

Aromas of overripe pineapple, brown sugar, molasses, vanilla, and baking spices. Some woody notes appear later in the pour. The initial taste begins with a blast of molasses, then transitions to caramel and spice in the middle. A moderate lessening of flavor over time, finally yielding to a pleasant vanilla finish.

Ciera Witt 3.8

this is good, likely the driest rum I've ever had, but I do not plan to spend $50+ on a bottle again. perhaps closer to $39 if I found it. also the description here claims no coloring added but the label on my bottle indicates it contains added caramel coloring, so. interpret that as you wish I suppose

Elvin Gregory 4.3

Aromas on the nose - slightly medicinal yet sweet, with bitter dark chocolate & wood polish and charcoal. Upon first taste, the mouthfeel is like sour espresso, cocoa, wood, and vanilla. The finish leaves the mouth dry and slightly bitter on the tongue, yet a mellow burn in the throat.

13 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Aged Rum