Skip to content
Sip Curator
Port Charlotte PC5 Evolution
Port Charlotte

Port Charlotte PC5 Evolution

3.86 Decent

7 reviews7 ratings

92 critic score

Whiskey Scotch Islay 5 Year 63.5% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

PC5 Evolution marked the inaugural release in the "PC" series from Bruichladdich. This heavily-peated (40 ppm), 5-year-old single malt is bottled at cask strength, 63.5% ABV. With a production run of only 6,000 bottles, it is now considered a highly collectible whisky.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Peaty 70
Smoky 55
Herbal 50
Rich 45
Oily 40
Briny 35
Salty 35

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 4 parsed reviews.

Jacklyn Kendrick 4.5

Ingesting cleaning products won't cure coronavirus, but I'm unsure if a whisky exists that might. If there's one that could, which would it be? Port Charlotte PC5 Evolution. 6,038 bottles were released in 2006. The scarce bottles still available on the secondary market now sell for $500-900. Quite a price, if it's effective against coronavirus. This is the most purely "medicinal" tasting whisky I've ever encountered. PC5 is like fruits dissolved in 63.5% ethanol and 36.5% other chemical and organic solvents. Is there actually any water in here? It certainly contains butane, butyric acid, lactic acid, sauerkraut brine, and flaxseed oil. The peculiar smoke in this whisky is incredible. I generally dislike cheese, and I detest strong-smelling cheeses; however, I absolutely adore intensely flavored whiskies. In the mouth, its consistency is like engine oil. The whisky is merely 5 years old, yet it delivers an endlessly rich, rustic smoke that feels ancient, coiled within the seven unseen dimensions of string theory, only released upon swallowing and transitioning into the hazy finish. Adding a bit of water reveals sweeter notes, creating a more balanced whisky. You can find some milk chocolate, vanilla yogurt, and ripe blueberries. However, this whisky is so overwhelmingly defined by its sharp, potent smoke that these faint traces of pleasant flavors seem like intrusions in a boundless liquid that resides at the edge of understanding. I've never possessed a bottle of PC5, and I still consider my PC8 the superior whisky, likely because comprehending the sheer intensity of PC5 is beyond my capabilities. Score: *** (I am not worthy) Secondary market price: $500-900 My perceived value: $500

Mckinley Crews 4.8

The aroma isn't the best, but the taste is incredible. Red and dark berries are present beneath the well-balanced, creamy peat.

Valencia Jaeger 4.8

Enjoyed at Jack Rose in Washington D.C. 1 oz pour. It was delicious!

Randal Priest 3.0

Peat and sea saltiness

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Scotch