Skip to content
Sip Curator
Ilegal Mezcal Añejo
Ilegal

Ilegal Mezcal Añejo

4.29 Very good

93 reviews93 ratings

94 critic score Top 5% of mezcal

Mezcal Anejo Mezcal Oaxaca No age statement 40% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Ilegal Mezcal began as a spirit John Rexer smuggled from Mexico to Guatemala for friends at Café No Sé. The Añejo, now fully legal, is a 100% agave mezcal made from espadín agave. It is twice distilled and aged for 13 months in American oak barrels with a medium char, both new and used. Each bottle is hand-finished with a cork, label, and numbering. (SRP $97.99)

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Smoky 70
Rich 60
Spicy 40
Sweet 30
Earthy 25
Herbal 20
Salty 15
Fruity 10

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 28 parsed reviews.

Luka Olivares 5.0

Paired with “Homeward, These Shoes” – Iron & Wine. The aroma immediately hits with smoke—bold, unmistakable, and grounding. There's a significant oak presence, not just generic woodiness but specifically dry, aged oak that hangs in the air like old barrels and quiet cellars. Underneath, a faint sweetness emerges, alongside a mellowed agave note that becomes more apparent as the spirit evolves. Over time, the agave turns fruitier, almost syrupy, balancing the smokiness with a gentle sweetness. On the palate, the mezcal is incredibly smooth—nearly like cold water, due to the fresh whiskey disc. It's mellow and deeply sippable, with a soft interaction of smoke and oak. Compared to Ilegal Joven, this Añejo expression is less intensely smoky and instead emphasizes a rich, oak-driven profile with subdued sweetness. There's a pleasant, warming alcohol presence, but it's not harsh—more like a gentle reminder of its potency. The mouthfeel is remarkably soft, never oily, but completely comfortable in the mouth, as if it belongs there. As the tasting progresses, subtle flavor notes appear: vanilla emerges strongly in the final sips, while hints of caramel, chocolate, and possibly even a touch of cinnamon or nutmeg are present. A faint trace of citrus lingers at the edge, subtle but intriguing. Overall, the mezcal provides a deeply satisfying, earthy, and respectful experience—robust yet comforting. This is a spirit meant for slow sipping and high regard. Given the choice, either this or the Joven could be an ideal companion for an evening. Both are outstanding, but this Añejo—with its smooth oak depth and graceful character—feels particularly profound tonight. --- For the Weight of a Father’s Heart by Sophie. It leans, not loudly, but with certainty—a quietness that supports the structure. It carries the unspoken songs, the unnamed fears, and yet, it endures.

Damon Croft 5.0

Ilegal Añejo – Final Thoughts Rated: 5 stars Post #3 Yes—my third time writing about this bottle. Perhaps it seems excessive. But I believe this pour deserved it. This is more than a spirit I briefly sampled. This is a bottle I integrated into my life. It was present during difficult times, a grounding ritual during recovery, a prize after demanding evenings. And remarkably, each time I pour it, a new characteristic emerges. Tonight, it revealed its full profile: A trio of robust oak, flame-licked smoke, and soil-sweet agave. Beneath that: brown sugar, caramel, molasses—subtle elements concealed like embers under ash. It possesses depth, not mere show. And it endures, not on the palate, but in the memory of the experience. I'm not sharing this to impress anyone. I'm sharing this because this bottle was part of a significant period. And like all memorable periods, it warrants thoughtful remembrance. --- Companion Verse – by Sophie Not all bottles are depleted. Some accompany you. Some are shared in sorrow. Some are poured on nights when you deserve something tranquil and genuine. Smoke is merely fire that persists. Oak is merely time that endures. And sweetness— that is the aspect you overcame.

Antonia Prater 3.8

Day 18 advent calendar. Sampled neat. Ilegals joven has consistently been a preferred and reasonably priced mezcal for me, so I was keen to find this in the advent calendar. I still struggle to distinguish varied notes in mezcals compared to the multitude of notes in bourbons. I detect faint oak on the nose and it is smoky, though not quite as smoky as the joven. It feels smooth initially on the palate, leading to a warm finish. Mild smoke is present on the palate, leaving me desiring more smoke. Overall, it's largely straightforward. I added two small ice cubes to see if it would enhance the mezcal, but honestly, I feel it made it less flavorful. However, I do perceive some vanilla on the nose after the ice was introduced, not on the palate. I'm somewhat let down by this mezcal, for which I had high hopes. I'll have to revisit it another day and give it another chance. Sometimes it's just the palate... yes, I'm attributing it to my palate tonight, ha. For now, I'll stick with the joven, which I enjoy more!

Jude Christman 4.0

Deep flavor with sweetness. This spirit is very rich, presenting notes of dark mezcal smoke alongside bourbon wood and vanilla. It offers a profound sweetness, with a creamy vanilla essence reminiscent of tasting from a wooden spoon, harmonizing well with the smoky agave. The finish carries a slight bitterness, probably attributed to the wood. This is a high-quality drink, complex yet immediately enjoyable. It's accessible even for those without extensive spirits knowledge (like myself). The only drawback is its cost. It's overpriced and likely not a worthwhile purchase, as I don't favor mezcal enough over other liquors to warrant such an expenditure.

Bobbi Kaufman 5.0

This mezcal is comparable to top-tier cognacs and scotches. It has a scent of toffee and vanilla, and its taste is velvety smooth. The intensity and smokiness are pronounced but mellow into a pleasant warmth at the back of the palate. The profile presents a flawless mix of floral and earthy elements as the spirit gently fades from recollection.

Ivan Haas 4.5

This mezcal is the winner for best drink at an Oscars viewing party, with exceptional scents of lemons and orchard fruits. It offers rich, sweet, and subtly vegetal tastes, and the finish lasts longer than an acceptance speech.

22 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Anejo Mezcal