Caroni 16 Year Cask Collection (A.D. Rattray)

It has a powerful aroma. A subtle peaty scent is present, which carries through to the taste along with a surprisingly strong iodine note. The smell is rich, smoky, and sweet, with hints of cherry, toffee, and wood. The palate is high in alcohol, delivering a significant menthol impact. The wood is very noticeable, complemented by some unexpected mineral notes. There are traces of dark red fruit (cherry), but they are not overwhelming. It's intensely woody and astringent. I value its richness, but it might have been pushed too far, resulting in over-oaking. That touch of peat is definitely there, contributing smoke and menthol. In that regard, it bears a slight resemblance to mezcal. There are some firework-like flavors that recall popcorn kernels. It's a decent enough drink, but not a top pick.