Skip to content
Sip Curator
Red Saw Rye Whiskey

Red Saw Rye Whiskey

2.93 Mixed reviews

11 reviews11 ratings

Whiskey Rye New York No age statement 48% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This rye whiskey is produced at Honeoye Falls Distillery, located near Rochester, NY, using 100% grain sourced from Monroe County. The mash bill consists of 85% rye and 15% malted barley. This spirit is sold in small batches, with comprehensive details on age, barrel size, and entry proof available on the distillery's website. Refer to your bottle for the specific batch number.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 3 parsed reviews.

Hazel Ellsworth 3.0

This is a rye whiskey I produced. It was aged in smaller barrels, with batch numbers potentially indicating 10 years (early batches) or up to 30 years (later batches). I utilized Barrel Mill char 3 barrels and a mash bill of 85% rye and 15% barley. It was fully understood, and communicated clearly, that both the Red Saw rye and bourbon were young whiskies aged in small barrels. Consequently, there's minimal esterification and "aging" on oak. Instead, it's more of an "infusion" of oak flavors over a shorter duration. Less refined, less mature, and a disconnect between the whiskey and barrel characteristics. An unfortunate but necessary choice for a new distillery. The positive news is that the identical mash bill was aged in larger barrels for the Grist and Saw Empire Rye, alongside the younger distillations. It's the same whiskey, just aged in larger barrels for at least 2 years. This provides a good comparison between small barrel aging and standard barrel aging. Batch 1 Tasting Notes: -Nose: grassy, spicy, strong ethanol, muted oakiness -Mid Palate: young rye pepper spice, green apple, ethanol -Finish: lingering finish with subtle oak and white dog whiskey notes. Brief.

Ethan Valdez 2.3

Nose: A powerful rye aroma. Taste: Intense heat from the beginning, almost too much. It mellowed into a smooth, fruity flavor, somewhat like melon, as it rested on my palate.

Gage Schneider 2.0

Tastes young, with a lot of grain showing through and minimal barrel influence. Not my preference.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Rye
Re:Find Rye
Re:Find

Re:Find Rye

Rye California
4.1 /5 14 $30–$50