Pinhook Single Barrel Vertical Series Rye Whiskey Aged 8 Years

Selected by Uncorked, "Gallenstein Selection #6" Barrel No. 3026 Age: 8 years 55.7% ABV; 111.5 proof Opened 5 months ago Nose: Predominantly clove and allspice, with cinnamon, burnt rye bread, toffee, brown sugar, pine, tobacco, strong oak presence, and moderate ethanol. Palate: Black pepper, clove, star anise, molasses, charred oak, tobacco, and maple. The finish is medium-long, featuring dry oak, black pepper, cinnamon syrup, black licorice, cherry pit, and moderate ethanol. I was highly anticipating this selection, but it's ultimately a bit underwhelming. Over the past year, I've purchased 6-year cask strength ryes from OKI and The Senator, and I expected this to be a significant improvement given the extra two years. It isn't. All three taste remarkably similar, leading me to believe that other 6-8 year MGP ryes offer comparable experiences. To be clear, the value is good, as this is priced similarly to The Senator and OKI. However, the flavor complexity isn't enhanced. Frankly, I prefer the taste profile (and price) of Old Scout 5-6 year ryes. I find they have less barrel char and more fruit and sweet spice notes.