Skip to content
Sip Curator
Old Potrero 18th Century Style Whiskey
Old Potrero

Old Potrero 18th Century Style Whiskey

3.31 Mixed reviews

77 reviews77 ratings

83 critic score

Whiskey American Single Malt California No age statement 51.2% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Produced at the Anchor Distilling Company in San Francisco, the 18th Century Style Whiskey is composed entirely of rye. It matures for 2 years and 6 months in toasted, rather than charred, oak barrels, utilizing both new and used vessels, which means it is not classified as a straight rye or a standard American rye whiskey. Given that the rye is malted and the product is distilled at a single facility, it qualifies as a single malt whiskey.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Herbal 80
Spicy 70
Rich 50
Vanilla 40
Oily 30
Tart 30
Smoky 20

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 21 parsed reviews.

Weston Brantley 3.8

A collector's item now, get a couple bottles if you find it available because Anchor Distilling can no longer use the Anchor trademark after being sold to Sapporo. This is an authentic and distinctive interpretation of a traditional frontier malted rye. Unlike many other distilleries that are merely putting on a show in a superficial way. This is well-made historical fiction, similar to "Gates of Fire." The color is light, the nose and palate are mild yet robust. Rugged and genuine, an honestly underappreciated rye and a new rarity.

Nikita Norman 3.5

This whiskey has a light golden hue with thin viscous legs. The nose is herbal and green and complex with notes of cinnamon toast, basil, oregano, Italian seasoning, green pine, wood freshly placed on a fire, dry straw, sawdust, and strangely enough, Play-Doh. The palate has an oily mouthfeel with notes of milk chocolate, cinnamon, rye spice, fennel, and melted butter. The finish is long with citrus and spice, concluding the experience. Cheers!

Margery Tomlin 4.0

After tasting this, a spectral figure appeared and advised me to pursue a more productive life path. My attempt to discuss economic shifts was cut short as they consumed my drink. They then gave a predatory glance toward our server before vanishing in a smoky haze. Awarded 4 stars.

Sage Anaya

Given the barrel conditions, this spirit lacks the profiles I favor. It presents as quite herbal/grassy, and the heat from the spice is intense, as anticipated from such an immature rye. I'm uncertain about the final taste, but it evokes the impression of very young and extremely inexpensive, lightly peated Scotch.

Tom Choate 1.0

Tastes like an orange liqueur to me. Anchor Steam is my preferred brewery so I feel somewhat disappointed. It barely tastes like a whiskey. Distinctive and unusual for sure. Excessively herbal and simply not my preference. Will not buy this bottle again. 2.0 ⭐️ / $75 / Beverage Warehouse / LA

Maeve Hanna 5.0

Allow to rest for about a minute. No water or ice. Appearance: Soft golden-orange colors, shows significant legs; Nose: Immediately detects baking spices, orange zest, maple syrup; Palate: Creamy, spicy, with nutty flavors emerging at the end; Finish: Smooth, enduring, beautiful.

15 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All American Single Malt