Skip to content
Sip Curator
Old New Orleans Amber Rum
Old New Orleans

Old New Orleans Amber Rum

3.25 Mixed reviews

12 reviews12 ratings

82 critic score

Rum Gold Rum Louisiana 3 Year 40% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Located in a 150-year-old cotton warehouse in an industrial area north of the French Quarter, the Old New Orleans rum distillery was among the first in the new era of American craft distilling. Old New Orleans rum is produced naturally, without additives or coloring, using high-grade cane syrup in a slow batch process. The sugarcane is sourced from Greg Nolan at LaFouche Sugars in Thibodaux. Old New Orleans Amber is a blend of aged rums, matured for up to three years in charred American oak barrels that previously held whiskey.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Oily 55
Sweet 40
Herbal 35
Rich 20
Roast 20
Woody 20
Fruity 15

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 4 parsed reviews.

Earlene Hebert 3.8

My view is that rum, much like whiskey, should be crafted with the intention of being exceptional for sipping neat or in an Old Fashioned. Many rums achieve this, in my opinion as a whiskey enthusiast. This particular rum does not. During my visit to the distillery in New Orleans, the guide consistently emphasized that this rum was specifically designed as a mixer. And to be fair, it performs well in that capacity! However, in my personal judgment, any aged spirit ought to be created with the goal of being excellent neat or on the rocks. Starting with a superior base product will inevitably enhance your cocktails.

Trista Young 3.0

The aroma is butterscotch with a sharp, spicy hint, possibly clove. It's followed by an oily, roasted toffee character. The flavor is unlike almost anything else I've encountered. It has a grassy, funky quality with a baked goods (perhaps sugar cookie) finish. Generally, it can be overpowering when neat; ice softens it. Despite mentioning sweet elements, this isn't a sweet rum. Frankly, it's not particularly enjoyable on its own, but then again, even the producer labels it as a mixer.

Olive Butler 3.3

The color is a nice amber. The nose is initially slightly strong on the ethanol. As the ethanol fades, notes of sugar and butterscotch emerge, although they are masked by a strong oily essence that is a little unappealing. The first sip is oily, with rich notes of charred oak and mild sweetness, with very subtle butterscotch. It finishes with mild baking spice. Almost no burn, very smooth. Overall, quite good for the price.

Atticus Parrish 3.5

Not as sweet as most rum but still full of flavor. Very smooth and easy to drink.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Gold Rum