Skip to content
Sip Curator
Mayor Pingree Orange Label Rye
Mayor Pingree

Mayor Pingree Orange Label Rye

3.29 Mixed reviews

8 reviews8 ratings

Whiskey Rye Michigan No age statement 45% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 4 parsed reviews.

Erin Bermudez 3.8

Okay, I admit I'm biased towards my home state's producers, including distillers, brewers, and wineries. However, this producer makes some really good spirits without needing that local advantage, with some amazing vodkas and whiskey. This is the first taste of their rye I've had, so I'm hesitant but hopeful. The aroma is like sassafras and a bit sharp, similar to a masculine cologne. The initial taste is more of that root beer and rye combination with a mild burn that fades quickly. This is an unusual dram because it seems to lack the strong pepper typically found in ryes, leaning instead towards a smoother profile. In summary, not as good as other offerings from this producer, but still a decent choice if you're seeking a smoother rye than most available.

Theresa Harkins 3.8

Batch 13, 94 Proof. I was intrigued; the nose shifted from typical high-rye notes of minty pine to a deep caramel. On the palate, I detected a Luden's cherry cough drop and hints of chocolate malts that carried through to a brief finish. It seemed thin at first but became more well-rounded with air.

Deanne Childress 3.0

Nose: Sugary, candy-like aromas, notes of rye, resembles flat soda or root beer barrel candies Flavor: Hints of butterscotch, peppery rye spice, a warming sensation that endures

Barney Ross 3.5

Nose: cotton candy, orange, caramel candy Palate: werthers original Finish: Rye, anise,

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Rye
Re:Find Rye
Re:Find

Re:Find Rye

Rye California
4.1 /5 14 $30–$50