Skip to content
Sip Curator
Islay Storm
Islay

Islay Storm

3.17 Mixed reviews

95 reviews95 ratings

Whiskey Scotch Islay No age statement 40% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Islay Storm is an Islay single malt scotch that is available at Trader Joe's. The Vintage Malt Whisky Company Ltd., which is more recognized for Finlaggan and The Ileach, produces this scotch. It is bottled at 40% ABV.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 38 parsed reviews.

Russel Holt 1.8

(Vita Dulcis Advent Calendar 16/24) A delicate, light aroma that strongly evokes Islay with its characteristic peat notes. It's quite reserved, and the 40% ABV is noticeable. However, it's certainly pleasant. I understand it's partly Finlaggan, which I've previously enjoyed from this calendar. Beyond the peat, there's pure white fruit/grape sugar and bright apple juice. The peat is its only truly compelling aspect. The taste is sweet, with the cold ash from a burnt fireplace. The finish, however, is surprisingly terrible. It starts acceptably but quickly becomes very unpleasant. Whether this is due to the batch used for samples or something else, the finish resembles burnt plastic and glue – almost chemical, like snail poison. I cannot finish the glass. Nose: 3 Palate: 2.5 Finish: 1

Jaime Rubio 2.0

Nose: Intense peat, not mellow smoke. It's like peat smoke on fresh asphalt. Also, tobacco pouch and leather. Evokes an old man's local bar. Palate: A sting of alcohol. Honey. The finish is brief, a burn with a whisper of peat. It offers a fleeting impression of what peated scotch should taste like, then vanishes, leaving you pondering the sip. This is a budget-friendly Islay. Suitable as a post-work, daily dram. Consider it the boxed wine of scotch – acceptable for daily sipping, but perhaps not for entertaining guests. Despite this, its reliably unremarkable nature makes it a worthwhile purchase.

Earlene Argueta 2.8

Gentle yet distinct smoke. Similar to what others noted, it seems a bit diluted as the finish is nearly absent. Still, it's enjoyable enough to bring to any BYOB house concerts I attend, as I don't mind sharing this for about $21 a bottle! Especially since most people there are drinking cheap beer. I'll be a legend!

Osvaldo Goode 3.5

Smoky as anticipated. Clearly not in the same league as the premium Islay scotches, but at $20 per bottle compared to the $80+ price of those others, it will more frequently satisfy my Islay scotch cravings than the expensive bottles.

Elwood Greco 3.0

A good amount of smoke, with hints of medicine and ash. There are a few discernible baking spices, but not much else. It might satisfy an Islay craving if found on discount, but it's not particularly great for me.

Geoffrey Andersen 3.0

A subtle peaty aroma accompanied by sweetness. The flavor is acceptable with a somewhat unwelcome initial and lingering sweetness. Spice remains on the tongue with minimal peat presence.

32 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Scotch