Skip to content
Sip Curator
Craigellachie 51 Year
Craigellachie

Craigellachie 51 Year

4.88 Exceptional

4 reviews4 ratings

Whiskey Scotch Speyside 51 Year 40.3% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

A single malt from Craigellachie, this expression was produced in 1962, during an era when the distillery employed coal-fired stills. The whisky aged for 51 years before being bottled at 40.3% alcohol by volume. This particular offering is a single cask release. In a surprising move, the brand intends to distribute this single malt without charge instead of setting a high price. Starting in late November, the brand will commence sharing the whisky with enthusiasts at exclusive global events, commencing in London. A temporary establishment named Bar 51 will operate at Milroy's in London from November 26th to 28th, 2018. The promotional tour is scheduled to continue to Australia, South Africa, and the United States in the subsequent months. A lottery will determine the 150 individuals who will gain entry via www.craigeallachie.com/bar51.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 3 parsed reviews.

Roslyn Flaherty 5.0

I was fortunate to receive a sample of this rare scotch and had the pleasure of sharing the experience with a friend. It was a distinct honor to finally meet them after years of correspondence. We learned that this scotch was produced entirely on-site, with malting and distillation occurring at the distillery, which had only two stills in operation. The barrel was left to mature for 51 years, largely as an experiment. Most of the spirit was used in blends, but this particular cask was bottled to prevent further loss due to evaporation, as the alcohol content was dropping below the threshold for scotch classification. The distillate was then transferred to refilled bourbon hogsheads, and this single cask was eventually released to a select few. The samples I received were from bottles 6 and 7 of a limited production of only 51 bottles. The color was a light amber, as best as I could tell in the dim lighting. The aroma was sweet and featured tropical fruit, primarily pineapple, with a persistent caramel sweetness and a musty note that suggested maturity, akin to old library books. This earthy, musty quality carried over to the palate, reminiscent of damp hay in an old barn, but not unpleasantly so. It also had notes of lemon polish or oil within a rich, leathery, peppery profile. It was remarkably well-balanced and surprisingly vibrant for its age. The finish offered a tingling sensation of cinnamon and ginger, eventually yielding to a long-lasting, dry oakiness. This was a wonderful, mature whisky and a truly special occasion. I doubt I will ever encounter anything of comparable age again. My sincere thanks to the distillery for sharing this instead of selling it commercially. It was a great whisky and a fortunate experience. I was glad to share this opportunity with my friend.

Finn Richards 5.0

A special thank you to a friend, I was incredibly lucky to try a sample of this. Only 150 individuals worldwide were chosen to sample a pour from one of their 51 bottles, from a single cask. I was a guest at this exclusive gathering in NYC. For a 51-year-old spirit, it is remarkably potent. The nose is full of pineapples and warm brown sugar. Yet, the taste is far from fruity. It presents as old leather, tobacco leaves, and polished wood. The finish evokes the sensation of being in an old cedar library filled with aged books. It possesses a regal elegance. I'm uncertain if I'll ever have the opportunity to taste a single malt of this age again. It was a memorable experience, encompassing not just the whiskey but the entire setting. It took place in the cellar of a dimly lit, cozy bar, where the upper level housed a sophisticated restaurant, but a long passageway led to a speakeasy-style bar in the basement. The tasting was private, concealed by curtains. It felt majestic and exclusive. Given that there are only 51 bottles from a single cask and just 150 selected individuals, I am grateful for having had this chance. My gratitude once more to my friend.

Merle Caballero 5.0

A person rolled down their car window while I was waiting at a stoplight on the sidewalk. They offered me a ride, which I took. Inside, they were unclothed and slightly intoxicated, holding a bottle of this whisky and gesturing with it. I inquired about a specific glass, but only a different type was available. Despite my annoyance, I maintained composure and accepted a pour. As I was about to drink, they spread their legs, and I felt pulled into a void. The next thing I recall is my alarm ringing, realizing I had overindulged in a different spirit the night before.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Scotch