Skip to content
Sip Curator
Atholl Brose Liqueur

Atholl Brose Liqueur

3.75 Decent

5 reviews5 ratings

Liqueur Herbal Liqueur Speyside No age statement 35% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Gordon & MacPhail, an independent bottler, produces this malt whisky liqueur, a combination of single malt Scotch, honey, and herbs, offered at 70 proof.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 2 parsed reviews.

Brianne Sinclair 4.8

Appearance: Like 18-carat gold. Aroma: A faint scent of resinous smoke, reminiscent of pine-scented chimney smoke barely perceived on the wind. A trace of oily peat aroma (camphor and iodine) and a suggestion of authentic, high-quality malt whiskey. Fine heather honey, delicate spice notes. Herbal liqueurs (Benedictine and Green Chartreuse). Herbal tinctures (oregano, rosemary, thyme). As it rests, the smoky whiskey scent becomes stronger - take your time with this superb aroma. Flavor and Texture: A sweet and smooth arrival led by spiced honey. Orange marmalade is perceived next, along with herbal extracts, some with a slight bitterness. Fleeting notes of anise or liquorice and cloves. A very subtle hint of smoke, so faint it's almost missed. The texture is rich and full but not viscous - it retains a certain crispness from the touch of bitterness and restrained sweetness. It is definitely sweet, but it gives the impression that the sweetness comes entirely from honey, with no simple syrup added. It has a long, sweet, and herbal finish, offering a warming and comforting sensation with just a hint of sweet mint in the aftertaste. For this selection of whisky liqueur tastings, I chose to save the best for last, knowing it would be. This has been my preferred whisky liqueur since my initial tasting. Dunkeld Atholl Brose is Gordon & MacPhail's interpretation of a traditional Scottish beverage, but they have significantly refined and elevated what is typically a robust homemade mixture into something truly exceptional. If standard Atholl Brose is a simple slice of vanilla sponge cake, this liqueur is croquembouche. Unlike most whisky liqueurs that use unspecified young grain and malt whiskey as a base, this one is built upon Benromach single malt, and its contribution to the liqueur is undeniable. They are likely using young Benromach, of course, but its quality surpasses the spirit found in any other whisky liqueur. They could legitimately rename this "Benromach Liqueur". Like all liqueurs, this is sweet - that's expected. However, if you don't usually care for this type of drink but are curious enough to try a whisky liqueur just once, this is unequivocally the one to choose. It stands to Drambuie as Ardbeg 10 stands to Johnnie Walker Red. Highest recommendation. "Excellent": 89/100 (4.75 stars)

Izaiah Cramer 4.0

Sweet, with honey and smoke.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Herbal Liqueur
Drambuie
Drambuie

Drambuie

Herbal Liqueur Scotland
3.8 /5 201 $30–$50
Bénédictine
Bénédictine

Bénédictine

Herbal Liqueur France
4.0 /5 74 $30–$50