I'd dare anyone to find a superior Irish whiskey under $50. As a primarily bourbon drinker, any spirit at 80 proof tastes bland to me. However, until you reach over $45, most options are 80 proof, except for this one. It's 92 proof and unfiltered, costing less than $30. The only other Irish whiskeys under $50 I would consider are from specific brands, costing closer to $40-45. I concede the finish is underwhelming, but the palate is creamy with a great mouthfeel and pleasant sweetness from the malt. Bourbon cask influence is evident in the vanilla finish, but it's too brief and has a hint of young ethanol. Still, much better than others.
Bushmills Prohibition Recipe Whiskey
Whiskey Irish Whiskey Ireland No age statement 46% ABV
Tried it?
How was this pour?
Score this bottleRating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.
About this bottle
A collaboration between Bushmills and Endemol Shine North America and Caryn Mandabach Productions, the official owner and producer of the British drama series Peaky Blinders, resulted in this limited edition Irish whiskey. Bushmills' Master Distiller Colum Egan created the blend by combining three, four, and five-year-old Irish whiskeys that had matured independently in ex-bourbon barrels. It is presented at 92 proof and is not chill-filtered. The bottle is designed to replicate a vintage Bushmills bottle that appeared as a prop in the television series. Sales in the United States commenced in June 2022.
How it tastes
Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 20 parsed reviews.
As a scotch and Irish whiskey guy, I was reluctant to buy this bottle. The reviews were moderate - neither good nor bad - and because it was inexpensive, I figured it had to be bottom shelf. And that's exactly where I found it one day at the liquor store. I bought it. Even mediocre, it was 46% ABV. So what the heck. I bought it. Much better than I thought. Not too sweet, a nice 46% kick, and unlike the distiller notes - I did sip it neat - and it was very good. Not great. But very good.
NOSE Banana malt, hay, dried orchard fruit, vanilla, honey, and a subtle hint of oak. It has a very agreeable scent. It's not intricate, but the existing notes are warm, deep, and buttery. PALATE Honied orchard fruit, banana chips, hay-like malt, Cornpops, vanilla, and caramel with a slightly metallic undertone. Again, not complex, but the flavors present are buttery and warm. FINISH Medium to long -> Honey, dried fruit, malt, vanilla, and orange candy.
It's quite interesting that Bushmill's Prohibition Recipe is a nod to Peaky Blinders. It's surprisingly delicious! It seems young but is quite enjoyable! The nose immediately offers lemongrass, cinnamon, and honey, with a subtle hint of green apple appearing later. The palate features more lemon, orange peel, and honey, feeling very fresh with a cereal note emerging towards the end. A very pleasant experience! Cheers!
The aroma does carry ash and that malty quality from the grain. With several sniffs, it almost has a lemon-lime vibrancy. Upon the first taste, it feels more viscous than Bushmills original, offering a typical shortbread cookie flavor on the tongue, followed by a bitterness akin to eating raw walnuts on the finish. Overall, I enjoy it; it's not as polished as the original and was worth the $29 to me.
Aroma: shortbread cookies, vanilla, cereal and apple. Taste: vanilla, sweet wheat and banana. Finish: creamy vanilla upfront that transitions into a brown sugar mid-palate with a nice vanilla on the backend that lingers a bit. While this bottle is not sweet like the standard bottle, I feel the extra ABV gives it a nice punch with a rich taste.
14 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.
Tastes like this
Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.