Skip to content
Sip Curator
New Liberty Bloody Butcher Bourbon (9 Months)
New Liberty

New Liberty Bloody Butcher Bourbon (9 Months)

2.80 Mixed reviews

34 reviews34 ratings

87 critic score

Whiskey Bourbon Pennsylvania 9 Months 47.5% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

The name "Bloody Butcher" for this whiskey refers to the heirloom corn varietal from the southern United States used in its production, characterized by its distinct red kernels. This corn constitutes the largest portion of the mash bill, supplemented by malted rye and barley.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Rich 55
Spicy 55
Sweet 45
Oily 40
Vanilla 40
Herbal 35
Tart 30

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 12 parsed reviews.

Korey Whiteside 1.8

Appearance: deep gold with extremely thin and sticky legs Nose: Fresh cut grass. The youthfulness is certainly apparent. Taste: Primarily heat and sweet corn. The mouthfeel is mellow, with a persistent bitterness on the back of the tongue. A strong hit of cinnamon and peppermint is present. Overall: Not particularly appealing. Essentially, it's colored moonshine. It doesn't provide a strong flavor in a cocktail, and the taste doesn't linger long enough to be enjoyed neat. Received complimentary at an airport lounge. Did not finish.

Lynda Searcy 2.5

To start, bourbon must be aged for four years. This was aged for only nine months. It's simply whiskey. Many purists are likely annoyed that New Liberty is labeling this as bourbon. Their tasting notes mention milk chocolate, butter, leather, and stone fruit. My tasting notes say... Hay. It tastes like dried grass. If this wasn't a gift, I would certainly regret buying it. It's not bad, but I definitely wouldn't call it good.

Claire Mays 0.3

I was deceived into purchasing this. I saw a new bottle with a '9' on it and mistakenly assumed it was a 9-year-old for $50.00...it refers to the month (mos.). That's what happens when I'm in a hurry. It tastes harsh, and I couldn't even finish my drink. I might try mixing it with soda, and if that doesn't work, I'll save it for people I don't like. lol

Pasquale Pope 4.0

Nose: Very sweet, almost like caramel or toffee candy. Cinnamon. Corn. Palate: Tastes of caramel apple and buttered sweet corn. Has a silky texture. Lacks oaky maturity, which is understandable given the 12-month age statement. Finish: A lingering finish with a very soft, slow burn, where cinnamon and caramel compete for dominance.

Rachael Simpson 2.0

It just tastes like leather. I don't detect much else. A bit of heat. The aroma also smells off. I won't waste it, but I might use it for mixing.

Daniela Odonnell 3.8

It tasted like the smell of rain on dry earth in a bottle. I sampled it at the Reading Terminal Market after requesting something interesting.

6 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Bourbon