This is a fantastic gin for specific uses. It shouldn't be your only gin, but its strong coriander and citrus notes complement certain cocktails exceptionally well. It's mediocre in a martini, decent in a G&T, and outstanding in my preferred gin cocktail, the Negroni (and its variation, the Boulevardier). I'd rate this a "5" for its Negroni performance; it pairs wonderfully with bitter elements and orange, likely producing the finest Negronis I've ever had. It can be a bit pricey for a gin with such a specialized strength, but it excels at what it does. If you enjoy bitter, citrus-forward cocktails, it's worth exploring a bottle.
Black Button Citrus Forward Gin
Gin Modern Gin New York No age statement 42% ABV
Tried it?
How was this pour?
Score this bottleRating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.
About this bottle
Jason Barrett's family manufactured suit buttons for four generations before he established a grain-to-glass distillery in Rochester, New York. This gin's foundation is locally sourced wheat, with prominent flavors from bitter orange peel, sweet orange peel, and Cascade hops from New York State.
How it tastes
Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 8 parsed reviews.
Clear citrus flavors define this gin, standing out from a traditional profile. It's not a substitute for a standard dry gin, but rather a good addition, particularly in mixed drinks where its citrus notes can enhance the cocktail's complexity. Consider it for a negroni, gimlet, water lily, or last word, but be mindful of balancing the drink, potentially reducing the cointreau in gin cocktails that already contain it.
A crisp, American Dry Gin from Jason Barrett, the founder of Black Button Distilling in New York. It starts fresh with notes of lemongrass, sherbet, and coriander. Its dry character adds notes of passion fruit, grape, orange zest, wildflowers, local hops, grain, cardamom, candied oranges, and Walkers Shortbread, leading to a powdery finish. May 2020
From a Flaviar Sample. It has a strong licorice aroma and moderate citrus initially. The palate has pepper and very little juniper. It's easy to drink.
Overwhelming licorice on the aroma, but mild heat allows lemon peel and botanical notes to come through.
Notes of citrus and anise make this very enjoyable to consume straight.
2 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.
Tastes like this
Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.