Skip to content
Sip Curator
Amaro Nonino Quintessentia
Amaro

Amaro Nonino Quintessentia

4.28 Very good

89 reviews89 ratings

90 critic score Top 3% of liqueur

Liqueur Amaro Fruili No age statement 35% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

The name "Quintessentia" signifies the ideal refinement of an ancestral family recipe for amaro. The foundation of this liqueur is the distillery's own grappa, which has been aged in several types of European oak barrels. An undisclosed combination of herbs and botanicals is then infused into this spirit.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Rich 80
Sweet 70
Bitter 50
Roast 40
Fruity 40
Herbal 40
Spicy 30
Woody 25

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 27 parsed reviews.

Beckett Koontz 3.8

This was the first amaro I ever purchased. My primary reason for buying it was for a recipe from one of my cocktail books, but after a couple of months, I decided to try it by itself. I was quite pleased; it was very smooth and encouraged me to explore other amari. It has been some time since I opened this bottle, so the flavor might have shifted a bit, but there's still more than half left, so perhaps not. It's certainly not my top amaro, but it possesses merits and performs well in mixed drinks. Regardless, let's move on to the tasting. The scent offers notes of spice and orange peel. The taste is bittersweet and quite syrupy, though less so than some lower-proof amari. The orange peel persists, and some stone fruit notes emerge. On the way down, there's a slight kick, but it's not intense, especially for those who consume whiskey or other spirits straight. Sweetness becomes apparent in the finish, which is actually quite lengthy. Nonino holds significant respect in the grappa world, and this amaro is crafted well, likely satisfying most amaro enthusiasts. I simply don't find it as exceptional as its price suggests. If the cost were disregarded, I would likely rate it higher. It remains a decent and high-quality after-dinner beverage, but I wouldn't spend the money solely for use in cocktails. For that purpose, I'd prefer Montenegro, which I think is superior and more affordable, or even common choices like Ramazzotti and Averna for recipes requiring amaro.

Delia Sebastian 3.5

Date: 4.11.22 Opened: 5 Months Served: Neat, Flute Last drink: Water This follows a 10-day alcohol break. Aroma: Dark chocolate, candied orange, fennel, hay, orange bell pepper. Taste: Moderate sweetness. Moderate bitterness. The sweet/bitter balance is similar to Cynar and Sfumato. A bit of alcohol burn. The bitterness persists. Tastes of orange peel and dark chocolate. It's nuanced and pleasant, but not nearly complex or captivating enough to warrant the cost. However, its balance makes it enjoyable to sip solo, unlike Montenegro. Among the few "light" style amari I've sampled, this is the best. If managing a bar, it would be financially sensible to find a suitable alternative for this in a paper plane, though it's currently the only amaro I've tried that delivers the correct flavor. Good, but not worth $50.

Cheryl Burdette 4.5

1.25.22 Served: On the rocks with an ice sphere Bottle Opened: 3 months prior. Aroma: Notes of chocolate and lemon. Flavor: A subtle fruity taste, reminiscent of a summer popsicle. It's a bit harder to discern specific notes when it's cold, but it's generally more enjoyable when chilled.

Preston Mccallum 4.0

Wonderfully light yet intricate. Rich, syrupy fruit sweetness, orange, subtle herbs, and a gentle hint of licorice. A very mild bitterness in the middle. Excellent on its own, and crucial for a Paper Plane. Costs $49 in Ontario.

Rhea Ngo 4.3

Aroma presents cardamom and intricate botanical notes, balanced by a pleasant sweetness that endures on the palate. It's akin to a sophisticated cream soda. Suitable for sipping neat or mixing into drinks. An experienced assessment aligns with this perspective.

Nathanial Neely 3.8

An unusual amaro because of its grappa base. The grappa is evident, but there are also prominent sweet orange peel notes. It's less herbal than most amari.

21 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Amaro
Amaro Lucano
Amaro

Amaro Lucano

Amaro Basilicata
3.7 /5 37 Under $30
Bénédictine
Bénédictine

Bénédictine

Herbal Liqueur France
4.0 /5 74 $30–$50
Cocalero Negro
Cocalero

Cocalero Negro

Herbal Liqueur Multiple Countries
3.5 /5 2 $30–$50