Skip to content
Sip Curator
Walter's Choice 44 Year Blended Scotch

Walter's Choice 44 Year Blended Scotch

5.00 Exceptional

2 reviews2 ratings

Whiskey Scotch Scotland 44 years 47.8% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 2 parsed reviews.

Leanne Monahan 5.0

Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm…exceptional! Truly magnificent! It tastes as though 44 years have treated this whisky wonderfully! AROMA: Absolutely sublime! It's completely saturated with sherry! Like an old leather armchair in a humidor, with notes of leather, sweet tobacco (reminds me of your old pipe tobacco from the Crown Royal bag in the filing cabinet), sweet cherries (perhaps maraschino), strawberry jam, Fig Newton cookies, very nutty, sugar-coated pecans. Beneath the rich sherry, there are tropical notes: sugar-coated dried mangoes, chocolate-dipped pineapple, maybe a hint of coconut. So intricate and complex! The sensations arrive in waves. PALATE: WOW! I could stop there. The sherry hits your palate first, and powerfully! Abundant sweet red fruit, more maraschino cherries, sweet strawberry jam; the palate delivers what the aroma promised. All the flavors from the aroma come through, and more! Sweet tobacco and leather, in the best way, complement the red fruits. A touch of cherry cough syrup, but in a good way. The nuts come through like Glosette peanuts and raisins together. Then some tropical fruit appears as the syrupy sherry settles, still covered in chocolate; the chocolate accompanies the entire palate. FINISH: Long and satisfying. After the sweet notes surge, a dryness emerges on your palate, providing contrast and a memorable conclusion to the experience. It brings more aged leather and some lingering oak notes, along with a hint of pencil shavings. The red notes persist as the palate dries, and there might even be a hint of menthol that remains, similar to the flavor left after finishing a cherry Halls lozenge. The memory of the waves of enjoyment seems to linger indefinitely on the back and sides of your tongue. OVERALL: This dram is the single best scotch I have ever had, and if I didn't know it was a blend, I would never guess. If there's grain, it's minimal, and I believe the blend is primarily malt. The maturation in sherry casks and the extended time spent there truly shine throughout this outstanding whisky. It's not a single moment, but a long succession of them, like waves breaking on a shore. Each wave brings something new while retaining what came before. The whisky explodes on your palate and, though it fades as all things do, it never truly leaves your palate. The memory of the joyous experience endures for a very long time. My dram was gone 10 minutes ago as I write this, and the gentle memory of what was a most memorable experience still lingers. A truly once-in-a-lifetime experience!

Jody Roldan 5.0

It's incredibly good, truly magnificent! It tastes like 44 years have treated this whisky wonderfully! Nose: Absolutely divine! It's saturated with sherry. Imagine an old leather armchair in a humidor, leather, sweet tobacco (reminiscent of your old pipe tobacco in the Crown Royal bag in the filing cabinet), sweet cherries (perhaps maraschino), strawberry jam, Fig Newton cookies, very nutty, sugar-glazed pecans. Beneath the abundant sherry, there are tropical notes, sugar-coated dried mangoes, chocolate-covered pineapple, possibly a hint of coconut. It's so intricate and complex! The sensations arrive in waves. Palate: Wow! I could stop here. The sherry hits your palate first, and with great force! Loads of sweet red fruit, more maraschino cherries, sweet strawberry jam; the palate delivers on the nose's promise. All the aromas from the nose come through, and even more! Sweet tobacco and leather beautifully complement the red fruits, a touch of cherry cough syrup in a pleasant way, the nuts come through like Glosette peanuts and raisins combined, then some tropical fruit appears as the syrupy sherry settles, still coated in chocolate; the chocolate persists throughout the entire palate. Finish: Long and satisfying. After the sweet notes surge, a dryness gradually spreads across your palate, offering contrast and a memorable conclusion to the experience. It brings more aged leather and some lingering oak notes, along with a hint of pencil shavings. The red fruit notes remain as the palate dries, and there might even be a trace of menthol that lingers, similar to the taste left after finishing a cherry Halls lozenge. The memory of the waves of enjoyment seems to last forever on the back and sides of your tongue. Overall: This pour is the single best scotch I've ever had, and if I didn't know it was a blend, I'd never guess. If there's any grain, it's minimal, and I believe the blend is primarily malt. The maturation in sherry casks and the duration spent there truly shine through this exceptional whisky. It's not a single moment, but a long succession of them, like waves crashing on a shore. The whisky explodes on your palate, and although it fades like everything does, it never completely leaves your palate. The memory of the joyous experience endures for a very long time. My pour was finished 10 minutes ago as I write this, and the soft memory of what was a most memorable experience still lingers. Truly a once-in-a-lifetime occasion!

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Scotch