In my opinion, Tamdhu surpasses Macallan. Its flavor and aroma are far superior, and while not inexpensive, it doesn't reach Macallan's extreme pricing. Tamdhu is renowned for its fully sherry-matured expressions, which are always perfect with a cigar. Following Dalmore's lead, Tamdhu has introduced this "Cigar Malt," an exceptionally dark whisky bottled at a solid 53.8% ABV. The aroma is absolutely flawless. Cherries dipped in chocolate, a wonderful scent. It's intensely sherried: dates; it transformed remarkably after a few minutes of breathing: lemon zest marmalade and glazed ham. It's like chilling a "Crunch" chocolate bar. Thick maraschino cherries, hazelnut, nutmeg. It's a stunning experience. The palate offers hazelnuts, almonds, very nutty. A dark rum character is noticeable, making it an ideal pairing for a cigar. Cherry syrup, orange peel, molasses, and quince dessert flavors are present. The finish is extremely dry; sherried and predominantly oaky. Nutty notes, including hazelnut, almonds, and bitter chocolate, are also present. It improves with each sip. Overall, this is the quintessential example of a "sherry bomb." It's akin to the final pour from a sherry butt. One of the finest whiskies I've sampled this year; Tamdhu delivers once again. My rating is 97 out of 100.
TAMDHU CIGAR MALT RELEASE NO.1
4.63 Exceptional
Whiskey Scotch Speyside 53.8% ABV
Tried it?
How was this pour?
Score this bottleRating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 2 parsed reviews.
Complex sherry nose with notes of raisins and herbs. It has a heavy body with good tannins, vanilla, and intense sherry character, leading to a long finish.
Tastes like this
Same style and price bracket, best rated first.