Skip to content
Sip Curator
Sisterdale Distilling Co. Straight Bourbon
Sisterdale

Sisterdale Distilling Co. Straight Bourbon

3.56 Decent

4 reviews4 ratings

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana No age statement 46.7% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Sisterdale Distilling Co. in the Texas Hill Country, established in 2020 by Chad Gailey and Peter Watson, presents its inaugural straight bourbon. This release comprises five Indiana-distilled bourbons made with white corn, wheat, and malted barley. Aged a minimum of 40 months in new, charred American oak, it is bottled at 93.4 proof and became available in Texas establishments in April 2021.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 3 parsed reviews.

Celina Maier 3.5

It's clearly corn-based spirit from MGP. It's neat to see young distilleries in Texas, especially from smaller communities. My main worry is how inexperienced these operations are, and how aggressively they are entering the market. For instance, the starting MSRP for this at my local big box store was a steep $80+ for a sourced bourbon blend aged under two years by novice master blenders. None of those details are particularly appealing. The spirit itself is quite drinkable. It has a low proof (in my opinion), revealing notes of light honeysuckle and cornbread, with a very tropical freshness and hints of caramel apple. The finish is very crisp with little lingering flavor. My conclusion is that I'm enthusiastic about these producers and they've put out a decent product. I wouldn't spend the money they're asking for it, but I'm happy they've launched. I'm more eager to see what they create in the future, like their own grain-to-glass offerings, single barrel, barrel proof options, and more mature age statements. They have a promising future, and I know they are capable of aging and blending spirits. Now, what else can they achieve as the brand develops? Show me!

Clarence Broughton 3.8

I hadn't heard of this distillery before; a relative gave me the bottle as a gift. I brought it out for tasting tonight on his birthday. It has a buttery flavor profile with hints of peanut butter and caramel. Quite tasty, and I enjoy supporting companies from Texas.

Nita Kemp 2.0

The initial taste is overwhelmingly harsh. It mellows out, but the flavors never evolve. It doesn't even make a good mixer with coke.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon