Skip to content
Sip Curator
SIA Scotch

SIA Scotch

3.25 Mixed reviews

59 reviews59 ratings

84 critic score

Whiskey Scotch Scotland No age statement 43% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

SIA (pronounced "See-ah") Scotch is a blend of Speyside (50%), Highlands (40%), and Islay (10%) malt and grain whiskies. Scotch enthusiast Carin Luna-Ostaseski curated it to "appeal to a modern palate." After extensive blind tastings, the final blend was determined to have a malt-to-grain ratio of 40% to 60%.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Sweet 75
Rich 70
Fruity 40
Vanilla 30
Briny 25
Oily 15
Peaty 15

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 31 parsed reviews.

Sheldon Merchant 4.0

A delicate, blended Scotch Whisky created by Carin Luna-Ostaseski in partnership with Hunter Laing and Co. Ltd.; a mix of Speyside & Highland Single Malts with a hint of Islay added for extra depth & character. It begins delicately with notes of lemon zest; mandarin orange & hints of clove; while the mid-palate offers a slight bite with notes of caramelized Crème Brûlée, vanilla, toasted walnut bread, a touch of cardamom & smoke; leading to a smooth & almost sweet finish with notes of hazelnut. December 2018 / January / April 2019 / February 2020 / October 2021 / August 2022

Tabatha Ha 2.5

NOSE Sweet honey, preserved orchard fruit, rich toffee, vanilla cake, banana candy, graham crackers, and a faint, farm-like earthiness. It's not incredibly complex, but it's certainly enjoyable. PALATE Rich toffee, orchard fruit, exotic fruit, honey graham crackers and more of that hay-like earthiness. Again, not incredibly complex, but this blended Scotch is outperforming many others in its class. FINISH Medium-short -> Dried banana and buttery toffee give way to earthy malt and a subtle metallic hint.

Agnes Hill 4.0

The initial aroma is full of vanilla and caramel, with a very faint hint of smoke. Adding a touch of water opens this up, but ice diminishes it. When tasted neat, it is very well-balanced. It has a light body and a very smooth, creamy finish. Adding water doesn't alter it much, but one ice cube brought out the smoke and brine. The smoke increases as I approach the end of the glass, but it never becomes intense. A nice, easy-drinking whisky.

Kerry Mcintosh 2.0

A straightforward whisky experience. The aroma is quite singular, presenting notes of creamy grain and a subtle sherry. On the palate, it's creamy barley and a singular Speyside sherry that builds and recedes rapidly, leaving a delicate Highland honeysuckle and a touch of saltiness. It's a mix of Speyside, Highland, and Islay. Suitable for newcomers to whisky.

Elisha Payton 3.8

Initial hints of apple. A sweet and lively blend. Very little burn. Adding a drop of water made the texture buttery, almost oily. It became less sweet. Adding one ice cube to chill it improved it over just water, but my preferred taste was neat, without any additions.

Richard Broome 2.5

Toffee and toasted wood on the nose. A strong wood flavor immediately, transitioning to a little caramel or sweetness, but a very oaky wood flavor persists through the finish. It's smooth, but I'm still unsure about the taste.

25 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Scotch