Skip to content
Sip Curator
Second Glance American Whiskey
Second

Second Glance American Whiskey

3.48 Mixed reviews

70 reviews70 ratings

Whiskey American Whiskey Kentucky No age statement 44% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Dave Phinney of Savage & Cooke, a Napa Valley winemaker, presents this new whiskey. Lots from Kentucky were aged for a minimum of 5 years in ex-bourbon barrels, then finished in wine barrels from Phinney's Napa Valley Cabernet projects. The mash bill is 95% corn, 4% rye, and 1% malted barley.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 24 parsed reviews.

Kacey Urena 3.8

Kentucky distilled whiskey finished in Napa Cabernet barrels, 5 years old, 44 ABV. Sampled neat. In the glass, it's a light golden brown with medium coating legs. The aroma is light, with notes of sweet grapes and grass. The palate initially presents baking spice and sweet burnt sugar, followed by vanilla, caramel corn, and tannic oak. The flavors are generally lighter, and the mouthfeel is thin. The finish has some sour wine notes, along with grassy rye spice, mint, and dry oak, lasting a medium-long time. It's dry. The wine finish is present but doesn't overpower this whiskey, adding a pleasant fruitiness but also an unwelcome sourness to the finish. I'm surprised by its spiciness given the low rye content (4%) in the mashbill, but I'm fine with that. It drinks like a higher rye whiskey, but with a softer and lighter overall profile.

Deven Hilton 3.0

Tasted three whiskies from Savage & Cooke and three from the Splinter Group last night. These are my quick impressions. 1 of 6 Seems youthful with grassy, spicy, vanilla, and berry notes. An unpromising start.

Madelynn Mcdermott 1.8

A gift – the aroma is somewhat subdued, and the taste is nutty with a clear wine finish. It resembles a not-so-great PBJ sandwich that I would probably trade for something else during middle school lunch.

Chase Pollard 4.0

I'd appreciate a bit more of that Napa Cab on the finish, but this is a quality, smooth whiskey I'd be quite pleased to keep on hand!

Becky Amador 3.8

A bit contradictory, possessing both smoothness and a fiery quality. It has a pleasant bourbon character, but finishes with a warm sensation more akin to rye whiskey. Good value for the price.

Reuben Hampton 3.3

Remarkably smooth. It doesn't do much to distinguish itself, but it's a fantastic value. A superb choice for a daily sipper!

18 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All American Whiskey