Skip to content
Sip Curator
Puncher's Chance Single Barrel Cask Strength
Puncher's Chance

Puncher's Chance Single Barrel Cask Strength

3.50 Decent

25 reviews25 ratings

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky No age statement

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

A single barrel selection of the brand's straight bourbon, this expression uses a mash bill comprising 75% corn, 13% rye, and 12% malted barley. It rests in new, charred American oak and is bottled at cask strength, with the proof typically around 108, varying by barrel.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 9 parsed reviews.

Ralph Moua 3.5

A barrel selection from Liquor Barn, sourced from Warehouse D. Fingers crossed this turns out well. I typically avoid trying new items without readily available details, and while I did manage to find some information after some effort, learning about your product shouldn't require such a struggle. The initial Puncher's Chance wasn't particularly engaging for me, but the prospect of an exclusive single barrel from Liquor Barn, especially at barrel strength, piqued my interest. Additionally, its origin from Bardstown, which I consider the heart of bourbon country in Kentucky, gives me hope that I'll enjoy this to some degree. For reasons I can't explain, I anticipated prominent cherry notes, but fortunately, that's not the case. Instead, the initial aroma was dominated by a potent cinnamon spice, which later softened to reveal subtle fruit and berry notes, alongside substantial oak caramel and significant ethanol due to the high proof. The proof, while high, isn't extreme, and it's the first element to make an impression, coating the palate with a pleasantly spicy character. I detect a hint of light fruit and some young grain notes, but the primary taste is typical bourbon, as one might expect from an experienced Bardstown distillery. The finish lingers for a considerable time thanks to the proof, eventually fading to leave only a trace of dark chocolate. I wouldn't be surprised if this involved 1792's mash bill or even represented their product directly from the barrel. Those who appreciate the 1792 small batch would likely enjoy this, and honestly, the differences would be minimal. Its price is slightly too high to be fully justified given the similarities, but its rarity as an offering helps to compensate for that.

Anahi Seifert 4.3

If you have not tried this whiskey at cask strength, you must do so immediately. The explosion of flavor, the smell of tobacco and leather. It is an essential addition to any bar. For $60, you will have no regrets. This is the word from a fellow enthusiast.

Richard Hardy 3.5

A nutty and sweet aroma, with a hint of wood smoke. Sweet peanut brittle hits the palate first, then evolves into slightly smoky oak. It has a pleasant medium to long finish. While not overly complicated, it's a very enjoyable, relaxing drink at 110.7 proof.

Drew Horne 1.0

Smells like wood, pear, and cinnamon. Tastes woody with minimal associated flavor. Warm.

Opal Caraballo 4.0

I have a store pick from a particular liquor store, and it's great! I haven't tried the original.

Margret Simms 2.5

Smells of oak, cinnamon, and pear. Tastes of wood, cinnamon, and wood.

3 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon