A shared pour from a friend. Nose: Quite aromatic, with floral notes bordering on perfume. A pleasant sweetness combines with good acidity, reminiscent of elderflower cordial, almost like white wine. Subtle maltiness and a touch of grain-ethanol appear on deeper inspection. Overall, a very intriguing and crisp aroma that feels revitalizing. Palate: Sweet with a significant kick of sharp ginger. The sweetness evolves into crisp apple and citrus. Not much else registers for me. The texture is pleasing, full and soft, with a nice lingering oiliness. Perhaps a soft, creamy element emerges as the ginger recedes between sips, but the ginger's prickle has intensified for me into a warmth that masks many underlying notes. Allowing more time between sips reveals a subtle drying, tannic oak presence, but it's minimal. The warmth is tolerable, but this profile strikes me as monotonous and somewhat generic. Finish: Medium-long. The oiliness contributes to the duration. Sharp apple and fresh herbal notes culminate in a juicy sensation. I find that appealing. I had low expectations for this drink. I've actively avoided J&B Rare since I first started drinking whisky in 2016. Everything is perfectly accessible, requires little effort to appreciate, and ultimately, while a bit generic and unremarkable, it's quite palatable. The initial aroma and the final finish stand out for me. As the dram concludes, I detect a hint of distant peat smoke. A surprise, I suppose. I won't be purchasing a bottle, but it's reassuring to know I have another dependable, straightforward option for when I'm out and about. (Pictured alongside a piece of Britain's oldest and most studied rock: Lewisian Gneiss. This rock dates back 3 to 2.7 billion years and is found throughout much of northwest Scotland and the Inner and Outer Hebrides). Whisky tasting #93
J&B Reserve 15 Year
2.94 Mixed reviews
Whiskey Scotch Scotland 15 Year 40% ABV
Tried it?
How was this pour?
Score this bottleRating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 2 parsed reviews.
Nose: Exhibits notes of apple, pear, and gentle orange. A subtle floral sweetness, akin to honeysuckle, is present alongside a background aroma of malted cereal. The blend of malt and grain whiskies is skillfully balanced. Palate: A mild, sweet entry with orchard fruits, a touch of orange oil, and a hint of ginger. The progression is subtle, offering little more than some vanilla and oak from the barrels. A trace of ashy smoke appears on the palate, unnoticeable on the nose, but it's very subdued initially. Towards the end, a mild tannic bitterness emerges. The texture is somewhat creamy with a silky quality, attributed to the grain whisky. Finish: Medium. Flavors include tart green apple, kiwifruit, mint, and marzipan. This is a substantial blend for scotch, significantly surpassing standard J&B. While there's a clear family resemblance suggesting a similar recipe, the components here are far more refined, showcasing 15 years of maturation in decent barrels. The nose is fresh, crisp, with good body and a pleasant character, free from overpowering ethanol. The palate is very drinkable, and with further sips, the subtle smoky background notes become more apparent. The finish is moderate but surprisingly longer than anticipated, with several tart flavors surfacing in the aftertaste. These are not unwelcome and provide a pleasing equilibrium. It's not an exceptionally complex spirit and might disappoint those who prefer robust, bold single malts. Nevertheless, it holds its own against other premium blends like Dewar's 18 and Old Parr 18. I found myself returning to it more often than expected, and with a bit of soda water, it makes for a satisfying and relaxing evening drink. "Above Average": 82/100 (3.25)
Tastes like this
Same style and price bracket, best rated first.