Skip to content
Sip Curator
George Dickel 9 Year Hand Selected Barrel
George

George Dickel 9 Year Hand Selected Barrel

Whiskey Tennessee Whiskey Tennessee 9 Year 51.5% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

The George Dickel Hand Selected Barrel Whiskey is part of the brand's private barrel program, which also offers a 14-year option. This Tennessee whiskey undergoes double distillation and charcoal mellowing before being bottled directly from a single cask after maturation. It is presented at 51.5% ABV, comes in its own packaging with an optional customizable vintage-style decanter tag, and each bottle is individually numbered by barrel.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 50 parsed reviews.

Harlan Chapin 4.3

GEORGE DICKEL HAND SELECTED BARREL 9YR(ish??) Barrel #: 14D02-21704 Date: 04/02/2014 *NOSE: Thick and Syrupy. Oak, Vanilla, Maple, Praline, Toffee upfront. Underlying Grassy notes. A whiff of Freshly Mowed Lawn and Hay. A touch of heat is the only drawback I detect. *NEAT: The Syrupy Sweetness persists. A Heavy Coating Mouthfeel. Oak, Cherry Cola, Maple, Vanilla. A pleasant warming finish with a feeling of warmth spreading in the chest. There's a faint medicinal note on the finish that lingers. Cherry Cough Syrup? It adheres stubbornly, coating the tongue, teeth, gums, and cheeks. Quite good. *SPLASH: Brings out some Tannins and a bit of the Flintstone Vitamin character associated with Cascade Hollow. A slight Bitterness on the Finish. Not enough to spoil it, but it's certainly superior neat. *VERDICT: My fondness for all things Cascade Hollow took a significant blow with the 15YR release. However, the 11 and 13 year BIB’s have remained stellar, and the Dickel 8YR Bourbon is very solid. This remarkable Hand Selected Barrel reminds me that George Dickel deserves a place back in my regular rotation. 4.25 **I believe this might be closer to 10-11 years old. It was barreled in April of 2014 and was new to the shelf at the VA ABC I visited.

Marc Nagel 2.3

Drinking this neat, from the first pour. This is a store pick, barrel number 144, 51.5% ABV. I'm detecting light banana, but also cherry? That's unexpected. There's charcoal mixed with what smells like nail polish remover. Lots of oak in this one. The finish is exceptionally smooth, as anticipated with the charcoal filtering. Once again, I detect oak and a leathery quality. I'm not entirely certain this is precisely what I had in mind, but that's the inherent risk with store picks, and with Dickel in general. I plan to follow this tasting with the 2008 fall release 9yr to compare.

Santiago Landeros 4.0

My bottle was acquired at John's City Diner. It exhibits the characteristic Dickel flavors: slightly fruity, a bit smoky, with a discernible mineral note. I detect ample sweetness and a pleasant, rich spiciness. Corn, baking spices, and charred oak are evident. The finish is sweet without any bitterness. This is a fine bottle for sipping.

Karissa Aranda 3.3

Summary: A sweet, nutty whiskey that evolves into a sticky, sweet cherry cinnamon pastry. Color: Light Gold / Honey Nose: Begins with a varnish-like scent, then opens to sweet almond with notes of cherry and grape. Taste: Syrupy sweetness with flavors of cinnamon, baking spices, and dark fruits. Finish: A spicy yet smooth medium finish.

Nora Newcomb 3.3

Nose: Brown sugar and maple. Neat: Sweet and spicy. Notes of brown sugar, vanilla, caramel, and buttered corn harmonize well with a considerable amount of spice throughout. The spice initially creates a harshness but softens into a pleasant spicy flavor on the finish. Overall, quite enjoyable.

Mikel Riggs 3.8

A quality bourbon. A little better than expected for what it costs. However, I would select a different bottle if I were to spend this much again. This particular selection came from Southern Spirits in SC; it's decent, but I like other store selections we've experienced more than this one.

44 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Tennessee Whiskey