So, a new bourbon, and given my strong preference for sherry finishes, I had to try this one. Nose - Dill, butter, young oak, sweet notes, a darker sweetness, burnt caramel. It's good. A word of advice: this needed significant time to open up; initially, it was just okay. Taste - Buttery, oaky, and indeed sweet. The whiskey seems young; it starts to develop a nutty profile, but I suspect that's from the cognac cask, which is unfortunate as they usually impart much more flavor. I worry they may have obtained some poor-quality barrels for this. Overall, I hope it improves as this is a fresh pour, and I will revisit and modify my review if it does, but generally, this is not a good bourbon. It's not bad, but there isn't much happening beyond some off-notes, and it's a bit too intense. Yes, I would definitely pass on this. Rated 1 star because it's still a quality bourbon, but there are no positive aspects, and the price is excessively high for the results. Bottle is now finished; there was a night it was working for me on Friday or Saturday. Anyway, the cask influence developed and improved with some air. I ended up enjoying it a bit more with that. I still feel this was somewhat underwhelming, especially considering the cost, but I'm more positive about it now. I almost wish I hadn't finished it just to keep it around. Oh well, having the shelf space is also nice.
Cassius Clay
Cassius Clay Symphony Cognac Cask Finished
1.50 Mixed reviews
Tried it?
How was this pour?
Score this bottleRating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 1 parsed reviews.
Boyd Garvin
1.5
Tastes like this
Same style and price bracket, best rated first.