Skip to content
Sip Curator
Broken Barrel Reserve Oak Series Finished with Peach Brandy Staves
Broken

Broken Barrel Reserve Oak Series Finished with Peach Brandy Staves

3.46 Mixed reviews

7 reviews7 ratings

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky No age statement 57.5% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 4 parsed reviews.

Carissa Lloyd 2.5

Challenging to describe neat. The nose is subtly of hard oak, with a bit of dark fruit, leather, earthiness, and a hint of peach. The palate is spicy, leathery, quite oaky, and peppery like cayenne, with an oily texture. The peach influence is minimal in the taste. A significant high-proof burn is present at the start and end, even extending down the throat. The finish is somewhat unbalanced, lingering with spice and pepper, a faint trace of peach on the roof of the mouth, and a tinny quality. With a small melted ice cube, some caramel emerges, alongside continued oakiness. The peach fruit influence in the nose is barely perceptible. Adding ice introduces floral notes to the palate. The water also brings out a turpentine-like, slightly metallic flavor. The high-proof burn remains spicy, peppery, and intense. Honestly, finishing this bottle will take time. It's not a subtle, richly flavored pour that makes you eager for more. This was my Friday evening drink after abstaining all week, and I expected a better profile for the $55 price. While I consider myself a strong amateur, there are superior $55 bourbons available.

Gabriel Everhart 3.5

The aromas were difficult to discern. Wood and grain alcohol for sure. Is it peach, or am I imagining it? Apple and vanilla. The flavors are present, but it's very hot. Extremely hot. It's challenging to get past this 115 proof. Fruit comes through the heat nicely, still like apple and (perhaps) peach. It's definitely sweet. Then. It. Is. Guess... HOT!

Carlee Harms 3.3

Sweeter oak with a touch of fruit. The alcohol content is definitely noticeable. Lingering finish. Not overly complex and could use a little balance. Good for a beginner's high-proof spirit.

Francisco Cosby 3.8

Packed with flavor at a high proof... quite enjoyable.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon