Skip to content
Sip Curator
Black Button Pre-Prohibition Style Straight Bourbon
Black Button

Black Button Pre-Prohibition Style Straight Bourbon

3.09 Mixed reviews

32 reviews32 ratings

Whiskey Bourbon New York 5 Year 50% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This bourbon is produced using a historical method prevalent in Rochester prior to Prohibition. Its mash bill consists of 80% corn, 10% malted barley, and 10% rye. It is aged for a minimum of 5 years in new, charred American oak and is bottled at 100 proof.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 16 parsed reviews.

Cindy Norman 3.5

An intense, grain-to-glass American Straight Bourbon Whiskey from Jason Barrett, founder of Black Button Distilling in Rochester, New York. It's made with a mash bill of 80% Corn, 10% Malted Barley, and 10% Rye; then aged for 5 years in American white oak barrels. It has an aromatic start of grains, wood, fruit, nuts, and spices; its bold development adds notes of caramel apple, butterscotch, toffee, and brown sugar; leading to a spicy, medium-length finish with notes of black pepper, oak, cinnamon, vanilla, walnut, and cedar. December 2023

Haleigh Colby 3.5

Feels stronger than its stated proof, with heat and intensity. It's not bad, though; there's a potent vanilla and caramel sweetness, complemented by wheat and malted cereal flavors. The body is medium-thin, and the finish vanishes quickly, likely due to the heat. It's good and enjoyable, but not well-rounded.

Silas Salcido 2.8

This one has a dry, almost sandpaper-like texture after sitting on the tongue for a moment. However, there are many interesting flavors on the backend, almost reminiscent of a cigar. Upfront, I detect some oak, suggesting this is a very young bourbon.

Mohammad Baron 2.5

From the 2023 Flaviar Advent Calendar - Day 5. Nose: notes of caramel, fruit, and chocolate. Palate: herbal, vanilla, and baking spice notes, with a spiciness that intensifies in the mouth after swallowing. Finish: spicy, oily, slightly bitter notes.

Kaye Acosta 2.5

The aroma features vanilla, toffee, and brown sugar. The palate is rich with butterscotch and caramel, accompanied by a consistent baking spice. It concludes with a long, sweet finish, accented by black pepper at the very end.

Nellie Jolly 4.0

Clear amber body with medium legs. Sweet caramel, toffee, and pepper aroma. Toffee, pepper, nutty, and spicy flavor. Medium-light body with moderate, low warmth. 8/3/8/4/17 4.0

10 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon