Skip to content
Sip Curator
Wheat Penny 1958 Bourbon Black Cherry & Toasted Wood Finish
Wheat

Wheat Penny 1958 Bourbon Black Cherry & Toasted Wood Finish

3.29 Mixed reviews

38 reviews38 ratings

Whiskey Bourbon Ohio No age statement 47% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This is the first release from Cleveland Whiskey to use a wheated bourbon mash bill (51% corn, 45% wheat, 4% malt), named after the year the World's Fair showcased the initial computer microchip. The spirit matures in new, charred oak and is then finished in cherry and toasted oak. It is bottled at 94 proof.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 12 parsed reviews.

Emery Iglesias 3.5

Woody, cedar, and a light apple aroma. Tastes slightly sweet, with charred sugar and some tannic raisin, fading into a mild spice and heat. It's not a smooth pour. However, the cherry wood is noticeable. Perhaps that's the tannic raisin note I'm detecting. I'll summarize this as harsh, but it's a decent whiskey. It's priced affordably, so I'm certainly not disappointed. It would likely work very well in cocktails.

Shayna Tate 3.3

This is really smooth and sweet. I'm glad there's no cherry flavor. Maybe red apple. Very drinkable. I think this tastes a lot like Uncle Nearest rye but MUCH better. Where Nearest went for cherry, this went for sweetness. My local store suggested it. I'm happy I took their advice. It's nice to try something different.

Paulina Whalen 3.5

Despite its reputation, I enjoy this. It's smooth with pleasant undertones. The black cherry flavor is present but not overpowering. The oak finish adds depth. As a wheat bourbon, it won't satisfy those seeking the spice of rye. I appreciate all types, and this offers a nice change of pace.

Micheal Darling 3.0

I'm not the most experienced taster, but I am a big fan of inexpensive Weller's, which is difficult to find in my area. I bought this for its wheat content, and it's definitely not Weller's. It's pretty smooth, and I don't dislike it. It's just not particularly exciting.

Larry Spears 3.5

Tried the higher proof version but didn't want to add a new bourbon. The grain flavor is hard to get past. The added barley grain dominates the initial taste. Dark cherry notes appear at the end, but it's an average pour.

Morgan Blevins 3.5

Appearance: dark amber red, reminiscent of Killian beer. Scent: woody, fruity, floral. Flavor: oily, wood, sweet, caramel, vanilla, cinnamon, with a warm aftertaste. Slightly warming sensation. Excellent value for the bottle.

6 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon
Weller CYPB
Weller

Weller CYPB

Bourbon Kentucky
4.2 /5 557 $30–$50