Skip to content
Sip Curator
The Prideful Goat 6 Year Cask Strength Rye
Prideful Goat

The Prideful Goat 6 Year Cask Strength Rye

3.93 Decent

27 reviews27 ratings

Above average for whiskey

Whiskey Rye Indiana 6 Year

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This sourced whiskey originates from Indiana and is a blend of 95% rye and 5% malted barley. It has been aged for at least 6 years and is offered at cask strength, which can vary but is typically around 118 proof. The bottling is unfiltered.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 12 parsed reviews.

Journey Sterling 3.3

The nose is quite enjoyable. A ton of spice with citrus and heat. You can tell upfront this is a high proof rye but it isn’t super overpowering. Some of the nose is sweet, like an orange citrus candy. The palate is really good. A great mouthfeel that coats in caramel and spice with a touch of heat. This really coats everything and goes perfect into the finish. So far the mouthfeel and palate are my favorite. The finish has a toffee note that combines with the continued citrus flavor. The finish doesn’t fade for quite sometime. The very end has a touch of pepper with the citrus notes. Overall, this is pretty good. I enjoy this bottle and happy I was able to try it. Would I buy it again, I’m not too sure. $55 isn’t a bad price but I do like other ryes better. I’m happy to try this bottle and even tested it as an old fashioned. Does really well!

Camille Ingle 4.3

Prideful Goat Single Barrel Chosen for Bourbon Real Talk Plus 114.2 Proof 57.1% ABV Bottle 186 Bought from Seelbachs Aroma- honey graham crackers, toffee, and apple pie, toasted marshmallow, freshly ground black pepper. As it opens up, I detect more cinnamon and baking rye spices. Incredible smell. Taste - Lots of toffee and fall apple cider donut flavors. A slight hint of bitter dark chocolate. A pleasant vanilla finish with a rye character. Overall - The aroma is superior to the taste. It has a medium viscosity, and the finish is quite nice. The palate isn't complex, but it's not as spicy as most 95/5 ryes. Honestly, I wouldn't have guessed it was a 95/5 rye. It's definitely on the sweeter side. Absolutely worth the cost. This seems like a rye for bourbon fans, offering more dark notes than rye characteristics. 4.3

Victor Reese 3.5

The aroma was quite typical of MGP 95/5 rye. It had rye spice, herbal notes, and dill, but a hint of ethanol was present. I enjoyed the palate more than the nose. The taste was classic rye. The finish wasn't particularly long. I'm happy to own it and will certainly drink it, though I probably wouldn't purchase another bottle. It's definitely one you should sample before buying, as it's not the most affordable bottle. Once again, it's not bad, just pricey for what it offers. The author's handle has been removed.

Virginia Galvin 4.0

Nose: Cherry cola, pie crust, nutmeg. Taste: Intense heat, cinnamon, cherries, bitters, black pepper (reminiscent of cherry cola). This is definitely a spicy one. It's hot but rich and full-bodied, a solid pour if you can handle the intensity.

Mathew Guthrie 2.8

Spicy with minimal sweetness (likely due to the 95% corn, 5% malted barley mash bill). A bit disappointing as I was anticipating this brand, but in a blind comparison, it ranked third out of three, behind Alberta Premium and Templeton 6 year.

Cordell Bourgeois 4.5

Earthy, citrusy orange and pine aroma with a tangy, citrus burnt orange and light pine taste. A short toasted orange finish.

6 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Rye