Skip to content
Sip Curator
Starlight Carl T. Huber's Signature Bourbon
Starlight

Starlight Carl T. Huber's Signature Bourbon

3.78 Decent

66 reviews66 ratings

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 4 Year 46% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This expression is named in honor of Carl T. Huber, the grandfather of Greg and Ted Huber, who are sixth-generation proprietors of Huber's Orchard and winery, as well as Starlight Distillery. The mash bill consists of 58% corn, 27% rye, and 15% malted barley, distilled in the distillery's 80-gallon German copper pot still. It matures for at least four years in new, charred 53-gallon oak barrels from three different cooperages with varied styles, and is bottled at 92 proof.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 23 parsed reviews.

Cheri Gossett 3.8

Some bourbon enthusiasts I know aren't fond of this spirit. I, however, am. It's one of the rare craft whiskeys I've sampled outside of Kentucky that doesn't taste like young cough syrup and oak. Nose: reminiscent of a wheated bourbon (it's part of one of the mashbills) — cherries, oak, leather. Taste: somewhat brittle, quite sweet, with hints of nutmeg and other baking spices. Finish: medium. At four years old, it's a rather good, uncomplicated sipper. It's certainly not bad. I'd be interested in trying some of their barrel selections and finished whiskeys.

Tanya Kiefer 3.8

This is a quality spirit, especially considering its youth and origin from a new distillery. It has sufficient flavor to be thoroughly enjoyed neat, and I'm confident it would excel in cocktails. It possesses a smoothness that complements classic bourbon characteristics, along with enough spice to keep you engaged. The finish is also quite lengthy. Considering the price, it's an obvious choice. I'm keen to sample some of their recently released single barrels; this one is a blend of two distinct mash bills.

Roderick Jensen 4.3

Aromas of caramel and hazelnut, with anise appearing toward the end. The taste brings chocolate, a fleeting touch of dark fruits, then shifts to prominent citrus. The finish is brief and vibrant, with citrus notes lingering. This is a very distinctive character, particularly for a four-year-old bottling. To put it plainly, it's the most intricate bourbon I've ever had that isn't barrel proof. I strongly suggest it, especially considering its affordable cost.

Fay Morgan 4.5

The aroma presents lovely dark cherry notes alongside touches of mocha. I didn't anticipate much because the Carl T is a young spirit at only 4 years and quite affordable, but it truly amazes me. The palate is full of rich bourbon character with a minimal burn. The lingering aftertaste features chocolate-covered cherry. Typically, I score on a 100-point system. This one earns a 94!

Andres Amato 3.8

Smell: Light and easy going, corn mixed with honey. Very pleasant and sweet. Secondary notes of sawmill Notes: Tongue tip and enjoyable spicy back, a bit of an ethanol note catches (taking away from an overall enjoyable bourbon.) End: Opens heavier but transitions well, fairly long finish for the proof

Jasper Tolliver 3.5

This one was a pleasant surprise! My first Starlight and a solid purchase for the price. I believe it cost me about $35. Smell: quite sweet, subtle oak Taste: upfront grain, hint of pine End: lingers for a bit

17 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon
Weller CYPB
Weller

Weller CYPB

Bourbon Kentucky
4.2 /5 557 $30–$50