Skip to content
Sip Curator
The Quiet Man Blended Traditional Irish Whiskey
Quiet Man

The Quiet Man Blended Traditional Irish Whiskey

3.36 Mixed reviews

253 reviews253 ratings

83 critic score

Whiskey Irish Whiskey Ireland No age statement 40% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This sourced blended whiskey marks the initial release from Niche Spirits, which has future plans for its own distillery. While the most recognizable figure named Quiet Man is John Wayne from the film of the same title, the inspiration for this whiskey is bartender John Mulgrew, known for his discretion with patrons' confidences.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Floral 70
Sweet 60
Fruity 60
Vanilla 60
Rich 40
Tart 40
Spicy 40

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 50 parsed reviews.

Devin Adler 3.8

I've observed this is currently ranked a tier above The Irishman Founders at Proof66. It's a blend of 20% malt and 80% grain, while The Irishman is a mix of malt and pot still whiskies. I was curious why the rankings seemed inverted from what one might anticipate. The reason is this is an exceptionally well-crafted blend. (Certain skillfully made and balanced Scotch blends surpass numerous single malts – consider Compass Box.) Poured neat, it has a pale golden amber color. The aroma is slightly sweet, with honey-citrus, and a touch of floral. The taste is vanilla, oak, some spiciness, and a warmth at the finish. These flavors are also present in the aftertaste, and they linger! It feels to me that the longer I savor this whisky in my mouth, appreciating the harmonious interplay of flavors, the longer the finish extends. I'm certainly pleased I decided to try this. The price is also reasonable, $25 in my area.

Elle Kincaid 3.8

Nose: Grains and oak. Subtle citrus fruits. Hints of caramel. A straightforward aroma. Palate: Sweeter than the nose. Vanilla is most prominent here, with honey appearing in waves. Fruity notes, mostly apples. Finish: Short. Warm. It's smooth initially but provides a small kick at the end. Overall Thoughts: I genuinely like it. I've encountered some rather unfavorable reviews or simply comments calling it average. The aroma is simple, but I believe it's a very well-made blend, and I truly appreciate the interesting complexity on the palate. This is the kind of whiskey I'd consider ideal for sipping before bed after a peaceful day.

Jimmie Espinosa 3.8

Aroma: honey, delicate bright fruit hints, floral, lightly toasted grains, butter cookies, a touch of vanilla cream. Quite typical for an Irish whiskey, in my opinion. Uncomplicated, light, but pleasant. Flavor: bright, fruit, honey, vanilla, a subtle herbal peppery note, baking spices. Like most Irish whiskeys, it's not overly complex, but still a solid, proper drink for the money. An easy, approachable spirit that would fit well into the collection. A decent alternative to Jameson if you desire a bit more from your Irish whiskey without a significant price increase. Just a minor improvement, but executed well.

Cherry Stokes 3.0

Extremely faint on the aroma. The most challenging whiskey I've encountered to discern an aromatic profile from. The aroma has vanilla and faint orange notes. On the palate, it presents wheat cereal and honey notes. The finish offers light toasted bread alongside hints of cocoa and mild oak. Fortunately, it has a surprisingly longer finish than anticipated due to the faint aroma, lasting a medium duration. There are superior Irish malts aged in bourbon barrels available within this price range, such as Powers, Bushmills, and Jameson.

Gregory Barba 4.0

Nose: butter, cream, slight vanilla, barest hint of fruit - apple or pear. Palate: butter cream, butter cookies, shortbread cookies. A slight breast taste comes in later. Finish: shortbread cookies with a very mild alcohol burn, more of a warming really. This whiskey is not complex nor amazing, but it is really enjoyable. It’s friendly and mild with no surprises, nothing unpleasant. It might be a bit boring for some people but there’s really nothing to dislike.

Devin Ahrens 2.8

Nose: I detect the hint of strawberry that an expert suggests. Very faint honey. Just a slight reminder of American honey (my go-to college drink). Palate: Light apple, vanilla, and spice. Required a little water to enhance. Overall, it's not mind-blowing, but it's a relaxing whiskey that's easy to drink if you're not a serious whiskey enthusiast.

44 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Irish Whiskey