Skip to content
Sip Curator
Handy & Schiller Barreled Old Fashioned
Handy & Schiller Barreled

Handy & Schiller Barreled Old Fashioned

4.03 Good

28 reviews28 ratings

Above average for everything else

Everything else Ready to Drink USA No age statement 42% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

This ready-to-drink (RTD) cocktail is named after the 19th-century New Orleans bar personalities Thomas Handy and John Schiller. It is prepared using Buffalo Trace Bourbon and Peychaud's Bitters, followed by aging in barrels at Buffalo Trace. It is bottled at 84 proof.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 9 parsed reviews.

Raymond Enriquez 4.5

I really enjoy this! It's convenient for having on hand ready-to-drink, and it's even better mixed with soda. I prefer this to the version made with other bourbon, likely because this is Buffalo Trace Bourbon. I'm not providing extensive details on flavor profiles, notes, and finish because my palate for Bourbon/Whiskey is still quite undeveloped, with over 50 tastings tracked but fewer than 100 as of 2022. (That's not all consumed, just all appreciated outside of shots and mixers).

Stephanie Lassiter 5.0

Perfectly balanced sweetness and oak. The finish has a hint of creamy citrus fruit with a nice overall bourbon character. Flavors include allspice, clove, vanilla steamer, peanut brittle, chewy caramel, and roasted nuts.

Camille Swain 3.5

A solid blend, perfect for an Old Fashioned using Buffalo Trace Bourbon and Peychaud's Bitters. It also allows for customization to your preference (I prefer extra Orange Bitters, citrus, and a dash of maraschino cherry).

Gloria Combs 5.0

An excellent old fashioned that requires no effort. To be fair, I've experienced a couple that were superior, but those were expensive, premium bar cocktails. Considering the price and ease of use, it's a solid choice. Salud!

Malakai Toledo 3.8

Normally, I avoid pre-mixed Old Fashioneds, but I picked this one up on impulse. It's a tad more intense than my usual, yet it was still quite enjoyable.

Aida Roland 4.5

A very smooth, ready-to-drink Old Fashioned. Using Buffalo Trace is a plus. A highly enjoyable beverage.

3 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Ready to Drink