Skip to content
Sip Curator
E.H. Taylor, Jr. Straight Rye
E.H. Taylor, Jr.

E.H. Taylor, Jr. Straight Rye

4.05 Good

1,129 reviews1.1k ratings

88 critic score Above average for whiskey

Whiskey Rye Kentucky No age statement 50% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Initially conceived as a limited offering using an old-fashioned sour mash technique, this whiskey has evolved into a popular, year-round line with multiple bottlings. Although the old-fashioned sour mash is no longer employed, the product remains excellent. This rye whiskey contains no corn and is bottled in bond.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Spicy 70
Rich 60
Tart 50
Oily 40
Smoky 40
Fruity 40
Vanilla 40

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 50 parsed reviews.

Karlee Reese 4.0

A balanced whiskey crafted with a unique combination of only rye and malted barley from Tennessee. Bottled in Bond and named for Colonel Edmund Haynes Taylor, a strong advocate for the 1897 Bottled in Bond Act, this rye whiskey is aged for 4 years before bottling. It begins with an oily and sour character, featuring notes of rye spices, wood, hints of dried peels, orange zest, vanilla, and linseed. The middle is rich with notes of cooked fruit, caramel, potpourri, rye, black pepper, hints of butterscotch, fresh dill, and prune. It concludes with a long, sweet, and savory finish of port, spice, and wheat. January / May 2018

Geneva Zuniga 3.5

NEAT NOSE - A very faint and unmemorable smell. Vanilla and honey. PALATE - Smooth, sweet, and enjoyable but unremarkable. Vanilla, lightly toasted oak, and some rye spice. FINISH - Short, with added juicy fruit gum and apples. BUY? - ONLY if you can find it at the suggested retail price and if you absolutely must have it, as I did. BUY AGAIN? - Most likely not. There are many ryes I would prefer that are less expensive, have higher proof, and more flavor (in my opinion). I'd also reach for them more often, leaving this to gather dust. It's good, but overhyped.

Jamel Noe 4.0

The aroma is a fantastic blend of creamy oak, bubblegum, floral rye, and sweet fruit. It seems very well-balanced and is unmistakably rye. It's very easy to approach and invites a sip. The taste begins with a rush of rye spice that builds gently, along with creamy oak and sweet fruit. It's quite simple yet packed with flavor, possessing a lot of body. The finish is long, spicy, and oaky. The taste lingers in your mouth and provides a bit of chewiness for more flavor. An excellent sipping rye.

Robby Dent 4.8

Damn, this is fantastic. Truly excellent. Almonds came to mind initially on the aroma. Then it shifted to menthol and mint... And botanicals. Florals, botanical notes, spearmint, menthol, with cocoa powder underneath and a hint of coffee. It's like two distinct flavor profiles. Coats the mouth with oil, which I adore. A touch of cinnamon. The finish is extended, rich, oily, and herbal. While a subtle sweetness lingers, it's clearly instructed to remain subdued... It has substance. Yep, a superb glass of Rye

Catalina Wood 3.8

Nose: Banana candy, spun sugar, clove, honey, scorched bread, peaches, general rye sweetness, ethanol. Taste: Honey, toasted rye, banana candy, spice, cherry, wood, caramel. A fantastic rye. Again, worth it if you can get it at the suggested retail price, but that seems to be a common issue with many products from that distillery. A little strong on the alcohol smell, but still amazing. Full-bodied, sugary, and spicy. It's not incredibly intricate, but it still offers a strong and pleasing flavor.

Rene Kopp 5.0

Excellent. The heat of black pepper on the scent evolves into white pepper on the tongue. It surely drinks like a youthful high rye bourbon, yet it offers much depth. Though no corn is present in the grain recipe, the toasted wood emerges with enjoyable vanillin that, after roughly twenty minutes in the glass, shifted towards mature banana for me. The conclusion is drawn-out and stings slightly (pleasantly) on the middle of the tongue, showing some cinnamon.

44 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Rye