All spirits Bourbon Scotch Whiskey Tequila Mezcal Rum Gin Vodka Brandy Liqueur Ready to Drink Everything else Taste finder Brands

Filters

Current selection

Old Carter Brand

Whiskey 72

Bourbon 41 American Whiskey 16 Rye 15

Easy to buy

Only bottles with a live Total Wine price, not out of stock or members-only.

Under $30 $300 and up

Tiers, not live prices: Under $30 through $300 and up.

4.5+ Exceptional 4.2+ Very good 4.0+ Good 3.5+ Decent Any rating

ABV %

Age (years)

Age filters skip bottles with no age statement.

Anyone 25 people 100 people 500 people

A thin score moves a lot with one more review.

American Blended Whiskey 15 Other Whiskey 1

USA 72

Kentucky 29 Indiana 9 Kentucky/Indiana 1 Tennessee 1

Clear

Brand

Old Carter

72 bottlings 4.35 median score $300+ typical price 324 ratings

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Batch 11 (2022 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon USA 54.4% ABV

Bourbon · USA

4.42 4.4 out of 5 33 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#26

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight American Whiskey (Batch 14)

Whiskey American Whiskey Kentucky 67.2% ABV

American Whiskey · Kentucky

4.63 4.6 out of 5 22 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#27

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Very Small Batch 2-KY (2022 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon USA 59% ABV

Bourbon · USA

4.63 4.6 out of 5 22 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#28

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Rye Batch 4 (2019 Release)

Whiskey Rye USA 57.1% ABV

Rye · USA

4.63 4.6 out of 5 22 ratings

$100–$300 Estimated range

#29

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight American Whiskey Barrel Strength (Batch 12)

Whiskey Bourbon USA 66.7% ABV

Bourbon · USA

4.33 4.3 out of 5 33 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#30

Old Carter

Old Carter 14 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Single Barrel #36 (2021 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 59.4% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.50 4.5 out of 5 22 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#31

Old Carter

Old Carter 13 Year Kentucky Bourbon Single Barrel #55 (2020 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 58.9% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.25 4.3 out of 5 33 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#32

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight American Whiskey Barrel Strength Batch 9

Whiskey American Whiskey USA 66.4% ABV

American Whiskey · USA

5.00 5.0 out of 5 11 rating

Under $30 Estimated range

#33

Old Carter

Old Carter - Batch 17

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 65.4% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

5.00 5.0 out of 5 11 rating

$300+ Estimated range

#34

Old Carter

Old Carter 10 Year Straight Bourbon Whiskey Batch SC-1 Bottle No. 92

Whiskey Bourbon USA 59.7% ABV

Bourbon · USA

5.00 5.0 out of 5 11 rating

$300+ Estimated range

#35

Old Carter

Whiskey Rye Kentucky 58% ABV

Rye · Kentucky

5.00 5.0 out of 5 No ratings yet

$300+ Estimated range

#36

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Batch 15 (2023 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 58.5% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.13 4.1 out of 5 33 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#37

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Batch 1 (2018 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon USA 54.5% ABV

Bourbon · USA

4.13 4.1 out of 5 33 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#38

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Batch 16 (2023 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 58.9% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.63 4.6 out of 5 11 rating

$300+ Estimated range

#39

Old Carter

Old Carter Very Small Batch Straight Bourbon (2-CA)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 58.3% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.13 4.1 out of 5 22 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#40

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Very Small Batch 1-CA (2022 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 59.1% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.13 4.1 out of 5 22 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#41

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight American Whiskey Small Batch (Batch 15)

Whiskey American Whiskey Kentucky 67.1% ABV

American Whiskey · Kentucky

4.50 4.5 out of 5 11 rating

$300+ Estimated range

#42

Old Carter

Old Carter 14 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Single Barrel #21 (2022 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 61.6% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.50 4.5 out of 5 11 rating

$100–$300 Estimated range

#43

Old Carter

Old Carter 13 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Single Barrel #93 (2020 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 60.5% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.50 4.5 out of 5 11 rating

$300+ Estimated range

#44

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey Barrel Strength Single Barrel Aged 14 Years - Barrel 8

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 58.5% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.50 4.5 out of 5 11 rating

$300+ Estimated range

#45

Old Carter

Old Carter 12 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Single Barrel #33 (2019 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 61.9% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

4.00 4.0 out of 5 22 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#46

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Batch 14

Whiskey Bourbon USA 58.5% ABV

Bourbon · USA

3.82 3.8 out of 5 99 ratings

Under $30 Estimated range

#47

Old Carter

Old Carter 13 Year Kentucky Bourbon Single Barrel #81 (2020 Release)

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 60.4% ABV

Bourbon · Kentucky

3.88 3.9 out of 5 44 ratings

$300+ Estimated range

#48

Old Carter

Old Carter Very Small Batch Barrel Strength CO-2

Whiskey Bourbon Indiana 61% ABV

Bourbon · Indiana

4.00 4.0 out of 5 11 rating

$300+ Estimated range

Best of the range

Highest weighted scores from this brand.

Old Carter

Old Carter 13 Year Straight American Whiskey Batch 4 (2020 Release)

American Whiskey USA

4.6 /5 18 $300+

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Bourbon Batch 5 (2020 Release)

Bourbon Indiana

4.6 /5 18 $300+

Old Carter

Old Carter 12 Year American Whiskey Batch 2 (2019 Release)

American Whiskey USA

4.4 /5 22 $300+

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Rye Batch 5 (2020 Release)

Rye Indiana

4.6 /5 11 $300+

Old Carter

Old Carter Straight Rye Batch 2 (2018 Release)

Rye Indiana

4.3 /5 17 $300+

Old Carter

Old Carter 12 Year Straight American Whisky Batch 1 (2018 Release)

American Whiskey USA

4.4 /5 14 $300+