Considering you've tried at least 80 spirits, you likely already know Macallan is often overpriced. In late 2021, this renowned and costly distillery launched a special bottling for the new year, named "A Night on Earth in Scotland." It's presented in what might be the most stunning packaging ever, designed by Visual Designer Erica Dorn, known for her work with Wes Anderson. The entire concept honors Hogmanay, Scotland's massive New Year's Eve celebration. The spirit itself is bottled at 40% ABV and has a pale amber hue. Initially, the nose offers a great aroma that quickly fades. It presents as a rich vanilla cream, similar to Coffee mate, giving a very dessert-like impression. There are also notes of biscuits and almonds, with a subtle yet pleasant citrus hint. My first taste brought prunes and sawdust, and little else. It's weak; the aroma vanished from the glass within three minutes. On the palate, it's quite thin, like plain water initially. Vanilla, a touch of lemon meringue, and a very faint hint of sulfur appear. A second sip revealed coconut. Quite disappointing. The finish continues the decline. There's orange peel, very tart and quite nice, but it lasts only a moment before disappearing. Meringue is present, but the finish is extremely brief. Overall, this is far too expensive, not due to its price tag, but because it doesn't deliver value. You might find it for around $200-250 and feel tempted to buy, but if you intend to drink it, you may feel you've wasted your money. After tasting it with twenty other individuals who agreed with these observations, I can confidently say the only reasons to purchase this are for collecting or investment, as the liquid itself is unremarkable. Pouring a glass of water from your tap would offer a similar experience. My rating is 71 out of 100. Please, someone, refund me.
Macallan A Night On Earth In Scotland
Whiskey Scotch Highlands No age statement 40% ABV
Tried it?
How was this pour?
Score this bottleRating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.
About this bottle
A tribute to Scottish New Year traditions, this release is the first in a limited edition gifting series from The Macallan. The single malt was created using a combination of The Macallan’s sherry seasoned American and European oak casks, alongside American ex-bourbon barrels. It is bottled at 40% ABV and had limited worldwide availability starting in October 2021.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 12 parsed reviews.
The stated proof is inaccurate; my bottle is 43%. The nose is rich with buttery shortbread, biscuits and honey, apple pie, and vanilla pudding. The palate has sugar cookies with vanilla, fresh plums, chocolate orange, and a light spice. The finish is subtle but satisfying, featuring citrus marmalade on buttered biscuits.
The aroma presents buttery biscuit, raisins, and vanilla. The taste offers sweet vanilla like honey with mildly toasted almonds, and fig. The conclusion persists briefly before fading with faint sweet toffee undertones.
I appreciated this as it was an easily drinkable spirit, though not what one typically expects from Macallan. The subdued sherry notes combined with the influence of other casks create a very smooth and pleasant dram.
Quite pleasant, a striking and smooth finish, excellent for sipping, with a strong flavor. Really good; offers solid value for $300.
Smooth and fragrant, with a caramel finish. A fine addition to my collection of Macallan whisky.
6 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.
Tastes like this
Same style and price bracket, best rated first.