Skip to content
Sip Curator
Old Forester President's Choice Bourbon (2018 Release)
Old Forester

Old Forester President's Choice Bourbon (2018 Release)

4.41 Very good

23 reviews23 ratings

91 critic score Top 7% of whiskey

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

To commemorate the opening of Old Forester Distilling Co. in June 2018, Brown-Forman has brought back a historic bottling. The President's Choice is a single barrel bourbon selected by current president and fifth-generation family member Campbell Brown, with guidance from Master Taster Jackie Zykan. The bourbon is typically aged for 8 years, though the precise age is noted on each bottle, and bottled at a proof between 110 and 120. The President's Choice is available at the Whiskey Row distillery in Louisville and at select retail locations in Kentucky.

How it tastes

Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.

Rich 90
Vanilla 90
Sweet 70
Herbal 50
Tart 40
Smoky 40
Spicy 40

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 11 parsed reviews.

Jeffrey Havens 4.8

Batch 13- 9 Year Old Nose- Caramelized banana, lemons, cherries, dark caramel, vanilla, espresso beans Palate- Spiced oak initially, followed by a wave of honey sweetness, lemon oil, baking spices, caramel, espresso Finish- Long, mouth-coating finish with notes of baking spices, caramel, and espresso Mmm. Wonderful stuff. You can immediately sense the age. Unique espresso flavors from start to finish. The best way to describe this is dark and rich. I would order this at a bar anytime if I saw it, but for the price, I would prefer to pay slightly more for Birthday Bourbon. Regardless, a fantastic pour that you should share with fellow bourbon enthusiasts.

Melissa Salinas 4.5

Taste #100. The aroma is a richer, more complex version of typical banana foster, with notes of butterscotch and toffee. The palate is well-balanced, reminiscent of banana nut bread but less sweet, with a hint of toffee. The finish is pleasant and viscous, coating the mouth, and it drinks lighter than its stated proof. My brother and I each got a bottle after speaking with Barb at the distillery in Louisville. It's likely my most treasured bottle. It has impressive legs and a noticeably darker color than most of my other bourbons.

Dustin Hitchcock 4.5

Sweet caramel on the nose, with a slight burn. The taste starts a bit hot, then quickly softens to a vanilla or burnt sugar/crème brûlée flavor. The finish has a gentle warmth, with lingering dark chocolate, dark fruit, and more vanilla.

Efrain Massie 4.3

This specific serving is from batch 29. The nose is strongly characterized by vanilla, char, and sweet cherry. The palate mirrors the Old Forester profile with char, vanilla, light cherry, and banana, complemented by a pleasant spiciness. The finish is long and warming.

Robby Heath 4.8

Indeed, it's that good. Don't pass it up. It's incredibly smooth in the pour and finish. Yes, it's expensive, but the pours at the distillery are a good price. Classic oak with a supporting role of sweet oak and leather, noted as buttery smooth with a touch of heat.

Joanna Leung 4.0

The aroma is sweet and intricate. It possesses a slightly medicinal quality. Full-bodied with minimal lingering burn, just the right duration. A touch of spice at the end and an oaky finish.

5 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.

All Bourbon