Lost Distillery Auchnagie

I've been curious about the Lost Distillery Company's vatted malt recreations of closed distilleries. I found three of them at a large liquor store in KC. All three are non-chill filtered and have no added caramel coloring; they all pour a light straw color. My purchases were Benachie--43% ABV--$50, Stratheden--46% ABV--$60, and Auchnagie--46% ABV--$60. All three display good legs in the glass. The Benachie has flavors of pie crust, subtle dried fruit, honey, and distinct peat. It's not an overwhelming peat, but it's very noticeable. The Auchnagie is similar, with less dried fruit, no smoke, and it's a bit sweeter with a pleasant spiciness. I would rate it a 4.2. The Strathden is comparable to the Auchnagie, though perhaps a bit sweeter. The spiciness seems more peppery, with a hint of smoke, and there's a mild astringency or saltiness to this dram. I give this one a 4.1 rating. I wish these were more widely available and at a lower price; there are several excellent single malts available that are equal to or better than these vatted malts at a similar or lower price point. That said, I'm glad I bought these and will likely purchase them again. They are unique and, in a way, works of art – the art of the blender. I respect and appreciate that. And I understand that matching the various malts in just the right proportions must be very labor-intensive; this will also be reflected in the final retail price. I wish they disclosed the whiskies they used in the blends, as Compass Box does, but that's just how it is. Cheers!

The Auchnagie has flavors of pie crust, subtle dried fruit, honey, and a distinct sweetness. There's a mild spiciness.

Sampled this at the whisky extravaganza. An interesting moment in history. This spirit is fruity, with notes of honey and citrus.

Very smooth, fruity - not entirely to my taste.

I had the deluxe version. It was terrible!!!