Skip to content
Sip Curator
Cream of Kentucky 11.5 Year Bourbon
Cream of Kentucky

Cream of Kentucky 11.5 Year Bourbon

4.06 Good

105 reviews105 ratings

Above average for whiskey

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 11.5 Year 51% ABV

Tried it?

How was this pour?

Score this bottle

Rating a bottle takes an account, so your scores follow you and count towards the number everyone else reads.

About this bottle

Cream of Kentucky, a brand revived by J.W. Rutledge Distillery under former Four Roses Master Distiller Jim Rutledge, was initially introduced in 1888 and disappeared mid-20th century. This bottling contains straight bourbons with a minimum age of 11.5 years, sourced and blended from 60 barrels. It is bottled at 102 proof.

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 29 parsed reviews.

Alvina Reardon 4.3

Nose (4.25): Less aromatic than anticipated but very enjoyable. Caramel, maraschino cherries, and some browned sugar are prominent. A slight astringency is present initially but dissipates with some air. It needs time to open up fully. Palate (4.5): Cherries continue from the nose, accompanied by some oak. The mouthfeel is buttery and appealing, coating the palate well. Hints of pepper and smoke emerge from burnt brown sugar. Finish (4): I expected a longer finish, but this one fades quickly. Oak is more noticeable with sweetness. It dries out too fast for my liking. This was a very good bourbon, but I believe a bottle should cost half the suggested retail price. When compared blind to ECBP B518, the ECBP won 4 out of 6 votes. That said, I would be just as content buying two bottles of many bourbons in the $65-$80 range. If you can get an affordable pour at a bar, definitely go for it.

Ashley Barbee 4.5

Aroma: Pecan pie, pears, cocoa powder, caramel, vanilla, apples. Palate: Pecans again, oak, cinnamon, red apples, caramel, rye spices. Finish: Medium-long and substantial, with red apples, rye spices, and pecan pie. The aroma is quite pleasant, definitely on the sweeter side, with a prominent pecan pie note alongside fresh fruits, vanilla, and caramel. The palate contrasts with the nose; the pecans appear immediately but soon yield to oak, spices, and some fruit. The finish, while not exceptionally long, is very enjoyable, featuring that familiar pecan flavor and delicious red apples.

Maurice Cloud 4.3

A sample kindly provided by a friend. Aroma: Vanilla is prominent, accompanied by a significant amount of poached pear. There's some oak, with underlying notes of grassy rye and an indistinct earthy quality. Flavor: Vanilla, dark sugar, and poached pear mingle with a generous amount of toasted pecan, evoking a fruit-infused pecan pie. It's delightful but sweet. Finish: Quite oaky with a bit of rye spice. The finish is fairly lengthy, becoming drier over time as the sweetness gracefully fades into the barrel notes.

Carter Gooden 4.3

The aroma begins floral and creamy, with notes of oak, coconut, and a hint of molasses and mint in the background. The palate is brown butter and warm with cinnamon, followed by mint, molasses, and a touch of oak. The finish is medium-long and spicy with cinnamon, mint, and brown butter. Eating spicy food negates the bourbon's spiciness, allowing the wonderful creaminess to come through.

Ginger Ibarra 4.0

I really enjoy this, but a friend tasted it and said it reminded them of armor all. Now that's all I get from it. I still think it's great, but I can't pinpoint any other taste.

Rocco Kang 3.8

Sweet, but it feels weak and the flavors disappear quickly, leaving only the alcohol burn. It's decent, but not worth $150. It would be a better value below $75.

23 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon